round 1, challenge 2: Be Kind Rewind voting

[herphotolife]

hi everyone. this is a day late, i'm sorry. if you're a member of my other communities you will already know this is because of problems getting onto LJ. unfortunately there were a lot of people who did not submit icons:

weatheredlaw // 2 skips
cherrygeek86 // 1 skips
gribouille // 2 skips
gt22 // 4 skips
lumiscious // 1 skips
lilacluv // 1 skips
lefthandpenguin // 2 skips
gurllie1994 // 2 skips
alwaysparis - 4 skips
father_a_w_a_y4 3 skips

Comments

[holmes221b]

least quality:
002 -- The icon is a bit too busy, it has too much going on in it.
006 -- The text is a bit hard to read.
014 -- The text goes wonderfully well with the image, however, the font could be better.

best quality:
012 -- Very well done, I especially like the text.
013 -- Very simple, yet quite elegant.

[lefthandpenguin]

Hey I posted a comment at the sign-up post showing my promo, so I think I should have one more skip?

[xoxoknlove]

least quality:
006: The text is so pixelized and doesn't fit the icon, it makes the icon look low quality.
001: The blending is good, but the composition of the icon is awkward due to random sizes of the images and the font doesn't match.

best quality:
004: Nice coloring and the font really fits the icon nicely.

[hermionesparkle]

I am confused, should we vote for 3 least favorites & 2 favorites or 2 least favorites & 1 favorite? I just want to make sure I vote for the proper amount. Also, you may want to screen the comments. :)

[taranouga]

least quality:
FIRST CHOICE LEAST QUALITY & REASONS WHY: 001: The text and the icon looks slightly low quality.
second choice LEAST QUALITY & REASONS WHY: 003: I find this icon a bit to dark.

best quality:
one BEST QUALITY CHOICE & REASONS WHY: 008: brilliant composition and texture!