hmm

Mar 24, 2009 14:01

did anyone else think the last half hour of slumdog millionaire was kind of weak?

slumdog millionaire, movies

Leave a comment

Comments 13

puddingdan March 24 2009, 22:24:32 UTC
I thought it was a decent film, I didn't even really know much about it before I'd seen it either. I think 'hype' is a fair critique in SDM's world.

Like I say, yeah it's all cool but it didn't blow me out of the water, yet for some, it appears to have.

Reply

acafe March 24 2009, 23:06:36 UTC
i thought it was hyped for sure.. but for good reason. i really liked most of the film... it was just the last half hour. the neat little package. the scar kissing. just.. ugh. and i did not buy the romantic aspect of it at all....

Reply

puddingdan March 25 2009, 20:32:33 UTC
Ha, yees. I don't know. I'm going through a phase of underawed by a lot of films...except Gran Torino, that was waaay above my expectations. Very clever little film.

Reply


horseygal57 March 24 2009, 22:48:56 UTC
I watched it not knowing what it was or that it was supposed to be this phenomenal flick, and I was absolutely blown away by how good it was. I thought it was fantastic.

Watching movies is all about expectations, I think, because I really can't say how I would have thought of it if I'd seen it after all the hype hype hype.

Reply

acafe March 24 2009, 23:08:06 UTC
well, it's true that i did have expectations for it... but the thing is that it actually lived up to those expectations for me up until the end of the movie. i just thought the romantic arc of it was not very believable (and i hated the scar kissing.. so cheesy...), and i thought it would have been a better film if he didn't win the game. it was just too neatly wrapped up.

Reply

horseygal57 March 25 2009, 00:23:44 UTC
I think what I liked was that for once the heros won. The end was really quite messy for most of the other characters....

Plus I really enjoyed the end credits ;)

Reply

puddingdan March 25 2009, 20:33:09 UTC
Not winning, just to add, yes!

Reply


tassiemap March 24 2009, 23:35:01 UTC
Yes and yes.

A little too sentimental and corney for moi but the dance during the credits made up for it.

Reply

acafe March 24 2009, 23:40:41 UTC
actually yeah, that dance was rad :D

Reply


mediaguru March 25 2009, 00:53:56 UTC
I haven't yet seen it.

Is it like Crash, where it's perfectly contrived and a bit melodramatic?

What's weird is that I found Crash to be those things, yet I still thoroughly enjoyed it... it got to me and affected my emotions, DESPITE how predictable and melodramatic it was. I felt like a sucker for falling for it even though I knew what they were concocting all along, but they did it so technically well that I just couldn't fault it.

Reply

bemyambulance March 25 2009, 03:20:42 UTC
It's nothing like Crash, in that it's actually good.

I was not super happy with the ending, but I was literally in tears from the beginning to almost the very, very end, and just when I composed myself, the dance sequence somehow managed to make me cry harder than anything else, and also made up for it. Seriously.

I'm a big sap.

Reply

acafe March 25 2009, 03:23:17 UTC
AHH! WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN!
i have obviously missed you :)

Reply


mcpenguin March 25 2009, 22:51:27 UTC
yeah. the rest of the movie was quite engaging, and it turned "typical" by the end.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up