Raping Harry Potter

Aug 11, 2007 20:15


Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 11

cindyg August 11 2007, 14:48:40 UTC
Worse yet, these people walk up to a public display in a bookstore, brutally rip the plastic off,

Oh, heavens, that makes the baby kittens cry, yanno?

Now, I'm no saint in the "jump to the ending" department, but at least I look for an open copy. (Which is why I love stores that keep an open shelf copy.)

I do buy the books once I know who stays alive by book's end...it's never spoiled my enjoyment of the books at all. But to tear open the shrinkwrap and then *not* buy the book? Eeep.

Reply


stuckeyvee August 11 2007, 16:21:14 UTC
I still have to read Books 5-7. Sigh. Need time to do that. God Bless.

Reply


anonymous August 12 2007, 14:40:43 UTC
Chill, man. That's how it is with the written word. The reader can go this way or that, skip, hop, go back, re-read or jump to the ending. Books are handy that way.

And reading the last page and putting the book back on the shelf, how does it differ from asking another reader, hey did harry survive? If all a person wants to know how it ends, it's their choice.

Besides, what do they really get (and what does the author really lose) when they read the last page? Certainly not the author's craft, not the heart or essence of her work. They get a bunch of words and a some information. That's not coming at all. Heck it's not even an erection. It's no reward, it's no gratification. It's nothing and if that's all they want, they're entitled to it.

-- JdelaCruz

Reply

agabot August 12 2007, 15:30:59 UTC
True, that, Mr. dela Cruz.

You can always fast-forward to the ending of a DVD, then when you've satisfied yourself that the movie will no longer hold any surprises for you, you can go back and watch it from the beginning.

Of course you can. But that still doesn't make it right in the sense that you are doing the people who made the movie or the book a gross disservice. But that's your call, of course.

I guess it's a bit difficult for those who don't fully understand the creative process to appreciate.

Reply


mrshobbes August 17 2007, 10:45:40 UTC
Oooh, I agree! I'm only just reading the book now, so have been avoiding certain websites and such against spoilers. Anyway, what's awful about THOSE people is they'll have random conversations with friends and will inadvertedly blurt out what happens within earshot to some poor soul who isn't done with the book yet. Thereby spoiling other people's cheer :( Shame, shame!

Well, bet those are the same people who tried their darndest to read all the spoilers.

Reply


hp7 anonymous August 17 2007, 14:04:45 UTC
you might want to check out what stephen king has to say. he has a different take on this with regards to peeking at the end of book 7

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20044270_20044274_20050689,00.html

Reply


Leave a comment

Up