Comments | alchemylab: (без темы)

technokittn in alchemylab

(Untitled)

May 31, 2006 19:09

Real quickly, can someone tell me if there is a huge difference between Samhain 2004 & 2005? And what are the differences? I got an imp of Samhain 04 last August and hated it then...now I am in LOVE with it! And I know it is harder to find. Thanks ( Read more... )

bpal chatter

Comments 12

finnuala198 June 1 2006, 00:21:12 UTC

Sure I'll go half with you. My email is aperfectsuicide at gmail dot com.

finnuala198 June 1 2006, 00:28:30 UTC

I need to lay down for a bit as I work overnight but I can provide feedback and all that jazz if you'd like. Just let me know.

technokittn June 1 2006, 01:22:50 UTC

Great, gonne eat dinner quick and will email you after. (I was laying down too, thats why I didnt answer immediately;)

finnuala198 June 1 2006, 02:29:29 UTC

That's okay. I'm just leaving for work in a couple of minutes so I might have to send you the money when I get off at 6 am central time.

Thread 5

ex_whitepho June 1 2006, 00:22:15 UTC

Dang it, beat me to it! *chuckles*

shelldoo June 1 2006, 00:56:31 UTC

i love samhain of all vintages but 04 is my overall fave, it is smoother, has more throw, and just an overall deeper more rounded scent, the 05 has a bit sharper note to it, however dry down is very similar it is just the first hour that varies imho

(The comment has been removed)

shelldoo June 1 2006, 02:00:14 UTC

yes it has mellowed quite a bit, but it reminds me more of 03 samhain, which still has that harder edge, although again the drydown is very similar

technokittn June 1 2006, 02:06:58 UTC

Its so delicious, I love it! I don't know what was wrong with me that I didn't like this at first. *runs off to find more*

Thread 5

the_cat_goddess June 1 2006, 02:09:59 UTC

Funny you should ask! : )
I just won half a bottle of 04 on Ebay, and while I like 05 better, I put on 04 last night and didn't take a shower this morning (yes, I'm dirty!), and I still smell it strongly.

I think I put it on around 5PM and a friend of mine stopped by around 9PM. Before I could shove my wrist under his nose, he stopped me and said he could smell it from across the room.

One dab.

lore June 1 2006, 20:03:57 UTC

I prefer '04 over '05. Shelldoo has the reasons spot-on. I was very lucky and won some '04 at a reasonable price on Ebay. People seem to be avoiding it altogether because of the reviews for '05....

love, lore