There would be a lot of answers to this, as I listen to a ridiculous amount of mopey sad music. But this one is flawless in its ability to turn on the waterworks.
Unfortunately, my choices for a video kind of stunk. There was a live version that I really didn't like much, and lots of bad cover versions. Plenty of the "I made a 'video' where the song plays while you stare at a still picture of the album cover" variety. So while I don't think the person who used this song for a fanvid did a very good job, at least it's the right version of the song and has schmoopy scenes from my favorite TV show which also make me cry.
Click to view