Haven't done this meme in a while.
Phibrezo (mamas_boy): 469 comments (0.35%), played from 2005-05-13 to 2005-08-01 (81 days at 6 comments/day)
Tenoh Haruka (acting_gorgeous): 515 comments (0.38%), played from 2005-08-16 to 2005-09-20 (36 days at 14 comments/day)
Daidouji Mayura (a_mystery_girl): 233 comments (0.17%), played from 2005-09-26 to 2005-11-01 (37 days at 6 comments/day)
Mello (dial_m_4_murder): 13,402 comments (9.98%), played from 2005-06-23 to 2006-04-08 (290 days at 46 comments/day)
Cho Hakkai #1 (_diesmiling_): 15,469 comments (11.51%), played from 2005-11-22 to 2007-01-15 (420 days at 37 comments/day)
Kubota Makoto (lovelykubota): 2,860 comments (2.13%), played from 2006-04-23 to 2007-07-23 (457 days at 6 comments/day)
Alec i Amasa (guidemyshaft): 763 comments (0.57%), played from 2007-08-20 to 2007-10-03 (45 days at 17 comments/day)
Hibari Kyoya (hibark_hibite): 1,469 comments (1.09%), played from 2007-10-13 to 2008-09-22 (346 days at 4 comments/day)
Marluxia (bisexual_orchid): 12,554 comments (9.34%), played from 2006-07-10 to 2009-02-03 (940 days at 13 comments/day)
Lexaeus (steady_as_a): 1,454 comments (1.08%), played from 2007-12-15 to 2009-02-03 (417 days at 3 comments/day)
EVA (a_classy_lady): 299 comments (0.22%), played from 2008-11-22 to 2009-02-03 (74 days at 4 comments/day)
The Collector Manikin (withallthatjunk): 2,481 comments (1.85%), played from 2008-04-26 to 2009-03-19 (328 days at 8 comments/day)
Jinana (vore_and_peace): 5,048 comments (3.76%), played from 2008-03-01 to 2009-07-10 (496 days at 10 comments/day)
Miyamae Kanako (lesbullied): 599 comments (0.45%), played from 2009-08-02 to 2009-11-26 (117 days at 5 comments/day)
Cho Hakkai reapp (vice_is_nice): 1,823 comments (1.36%), played from 2009-03-28 to 2010-01-21 (300 days at 6 comments/day)
The Riku Replica (cardoperatedboy): 9,418 comments (7.01%), played from 2006-12-02 to 2010-07-27 (1,333 days at 7 comments/day)
Umeda Hokuto (always_on_call): 26,929 comments (20.04%), played since 2005-10-17 (1,745 days at 15 comments/day)
Heat (vore_crimes): 16,416 comments (12.22%), played since 2007-01-27 (1,278 days at 13 comments/day)
Sakubo (machiavelliyaan): 6,566 comments (4.89%), played since 2008-08-23 (704 days at 9 comments/day)
Sahashi Minato (please_reapp): 4,636 comments (3.45%), played since 2009-01-17 (557 days at 8 comments/day)
Agatsuma Soubi (fragmentedimago): 6,569 comments (4.89%), played since 2009-10-03 (298 days at 22 comments/day)
Tsukihiko (onasmallscale): 882 comments (0.66%), played since 2009-12-12 (228 days at 4 comments/day)
Cheryl Shane Kates (lolitops): 1,189 comments (0.88%), played since 2010-03-13 (137 days at 9 comments/day)
Grelle Sutcliff (thebutlersawed): 2,056 comments (1.53%), played since 2010-05-22 (67 days at 31 comments/day)
Mutsu (masteredblader): 254 comments (0.19%), played since 2010-06-18 (40 days at 6 comments/day)
Total comment count: 134,353 since 2005-05-13 (1902 days at 71 comments/day)
Source
Tenoh Haruka (acting_gorgeous): 515 comments (0.38%), played from 2005-08-16 to 2005-09-20 (36 days at 14 comments/day)
Daidouji Mayura (a_mystery_girl): 233 comments (0.17%), played from 2005-09-26 to 2005-11-01 (37 days at 6 comments/day)
Mello (dial_m_4_murder): 13,402 comments (9.98%), played from 2005-06-23 to 2006-04-08 (290 days at 46 comments/day)
Cho Hakkai #1 (_diesmiling_): 15,469 comments (11.51%), played from 2005-11-22 to 2007-01-15 (420 days at 37 comments/day)
Kubota Makoto (lovelykubota): 2,860 comments (2.13%), played from 2006-04-23 to 2007-07-23 (457 days at 6 comments/day)
Alec i Amasa (guidemyshaft): 763 comments (0.57%), played from 2007-08-20 to 2007-10-03 (45 days at 17 comments/day)
Hibari Kyoya (hibark_hibite): 1,469 comments (1.09%), played from 2007-10-13 to 2008-09-22 (346 days at 4 comments/day)
Marluxia (bisexual_orchid): 12,554 comments (9.34%), played from 2006-07-10 to 2009-02-03 (940 days at 13 comments/day)
Lexaeus (steady_as_a): 1,454 comments (1.08%), played from 2007-12-15 to 2009-02-03 (417 days at 3 comments/day)
EVA (a_classy_lady): 299 comments (0.22%), played from 2008-11-22 to 2009-02-03 (74 days at 4 comments/day)
The Collector Manikin (withallthatjunk): 2,481 comments (1.85%), played from 2008-04-26 to 2009-03-19 (328 days at 8 comments/day)
Jinana (vore_and_peace): 5,048 comments (3.76%), played from 2008-03-01 to 2009-07-10 (496 days at 10 comments/day)
Miyamae Kanako (lesbullied): 599 comments (0.45%), played from 2009-08-02 to 2009-11-26 (117 days at 5 comments/day)
Cho Hakkai reapp (vice_is_nice): 1,823 comments (1.36%), played from 2009-03-28 to 2010-01-21 (300 days at 6 comments/day)
The Riku Replica (cardoperatedboy): 9,418 comments (7.01%), played from 2006-12-02 to 2010-07-27 (1,333 days at 7 comments/day)
Umeda Hokuto (always_on_call): 26,929 comments (20.04%), played since 2005-10-17 (1,745 days at 15 comments/day)
Heat (vore_crimes): 16,416 comments (12.22%), played since 2007-01-27 (1,278 days at 13 comments/day)
Sakubo (machiavelliyaan): 6,566 comments (4.89%), played since 2008-08-23 (704 days at 9 comments/day)
Sahashi Minato (please_reapp): 4,636 comments (3.45%), played since 2009-01-17 (557 days at 8 comments/day)
Agatsuma Soubi (fragmentedimago): 6,569 comments (4.89%), played since 2009-10-03 (298 days at 22 comments/day)
Tsukihiko (onasmallscale): 882 comments (0.66%), played since 2009-12-12 (228 days at 4 comments/day)
Cheryl Shane Kates (lolitops): 1,189 comments (0.88%), played since 2010-03-13 (137 days at 9 comments/day)
Grelle Sutcliff (thebutlersawed): 2,056 comments (1.53%), played since 2010-05-22 (67 days at 31 comments/day)
Mutsu (masteredblader): 254 comments (0.19%), played since 2010-06-18 (40 days at 6 comments/day)
Total comment count: 134,353 since 2005-05-13 (1902 days at 71 comments/day)
Source