6.13 Unforgiven

[amber3444]

Well,  I kinda  get used to the fact that good strong and light episodes as much as it can be in the show with such themes alternate with pretty ordinary, dark and depressive ones. So after previous interesting funny and calm “for once” episode for the brothers we have this:  simple and dark episode.

So in the beginning we saw some pretty

Comments

[scherwood]

hmmm... I agree with this. *thinking* *nod, nod*

[amber3444]

*smooches*

[xxsafixx]

I agree with you in some points,I mean Dean was the one who figured what's going on and what all we could see about is how much he was worried about Sam.I get that,I mean the writers are trying to fix the relationship between them.But going to same formula from season 1 and not in a creative way makes me a bit mad.I am not gonna lie,I enjoyed the episode but I still think it could be better.
For grandpa Samuel,he looks like he was scared of Robo!sam more than any supernatural creature that he witnessed in his whole life.But I think his days are numbered.Thinking of the promise Dean gave,yeah I think so ( although I love Mitch Pileggi,grandpa pisses me off:p)

[amber3444]

I enjoyed the episode but I still think it could be better.

The thing is that after season 5 we all kind of expected that the brothers' relationship acquire the new level that is real partnership in everything that is when each brother can be a leader and just a soldier, each one can protect and take care and accept that care and help, I adore protective Dean but I also want to see protective Sam, I like superhero!Sam but I also want to watch at kick-ass hunter Dean, but in the first half of the season we were presented just with some kind of superhero!Sam and some equally strange version of domestic!Dean, in addition no bond between the brothers, so when at last we got that bond back it - the variant of relationship like in season 1 was much better that nothing so I'm glad but really hope that things are to develop but in the right brotherly direction - strengthening of that bond.

[xxsafixx]

"but in the first half of the season we were presented just with some kind of superhero!Sam and some equally strange version of domestic!Dean"
yeah,couldn't agree more and also both Dean and Sam have been through a lot all those year,no one can expect them to be the same boys back in season 1.

what I want is from the writers to give a purpose to Dean in this season besides wandering around aimlessly.I mean I just can't accept that all he wants is getting a normal life!
Or maybe it's just me...

[etoile444]

But we know souls can be broken, that's what happens in hell. Your shiny soul goes in and slowly tarnishes to the black smoke of a demon. But Sammy's soul was still shiny, not demony at all. So I hold hope he was not tainted to demonhood that way.

I always hold he'd end up more like an angel anyhow.

[amber3444]

But we know souls can be broken

Yes, that was the concept the writers were consistent with, in other words souls can just change their quality turning the essence of a person from human into demonic - that was what happened to Ruby #1 and thing Dean was afraid of (even before he went to Hell), but at the same time the soul itself can't be damaged thus when Dean escaped the Hell after all the torture his soul was Ok and even his mind was Ok when he remembered everything.

So why it should be different with Sam?

Following their own logic of development of the show Sam should be Ok now as long as his essence - his soul remained human just like it was with Dean.