Comments | amberdulen: HBP

amberdulen

HBP

Jul 20, 2005 21:07

It...is finished.

Still processing. Recalibrating thought patterns for Book 7.

Feel free to spoil up the comments.

hbp

Comments 10

chocoholic July 21 2005, 01:22:33 UTC

yo tambien lo termine....

amberdulen July 21 2005, 02:15:30 UTC

Era mucho mas bien que el Orden de Fenix, no?

chocoholic July 21 2005, 14:47:08 UTC

Si, mucho mejor.

Pero hay muchas cosas que indican que ya casi es el final :_(

scionofgrace July 21 2005, 02:14:24 UTC

So... Snape. Evil?

amberdulen July 21 2005, 02:15:52 UTC

I. Will not. Give in.

scionofgrace July 21 2005, 04:58:34 UTC

Snape = Definitely going to turn out to be a Secret Good Guy

irked_indeed July 21 2005, 12:15:32 UTC

*blinks*

Okay, whoah. I was all set to argue that was ridiculous, and that there is a point at which, when you make being a Secret Good Guy that much of a secret, you're a Public Bad Guy.

But... but we don't really know whether Dumbledore was pleading with Snape not to kill him, or just to kill him. And with Dumbledore, the latter almost seems more likely.

DAD GUM IT. I was really enjoying hating him without restriction.

thistlemeg July 21 2005, 02:21:56 UTC

You were right about Tonks' problems being werewolf-related, you know. I was laughing out loud every time you came to it. *grin* And you even kind of called Fenrir's attack on Bill! I'm very impressed; I didn't even guess that Snape was the HBP.

Looking forward to your final thoughts and speculation.

foxyfennec July 21 2005, 15:18:26 UTC

I maintain that Snape is a good guy. I thought that 'Dore had been dying from the beginning of the book.

And Tonks? LOVE that she is with Lupin! Best couple EVAR!

I can't wait to see what you think about it! :)

lo_ex_nihilo July 21 2005, 16:24:21 UTC

Think about this one... the curse that "killed" dumbledore was defeated by Harry once a while ago.

Also, R.A.B. obviously got the real horcrux, so is it possible that the potion in the bowl was not what Voldemort had originally intended (although it did seem to be working as intended...) Eh, I dunno.