results session 3: challenge 4

[loving_w]

okay, i know, i'm terrible mod. but i really had no time.(( school sucks.(
and here are the results. ^^


Elimination:


meow_kiss || with -3 votes
I'm so sorry! Really loved your icon.((

People's choice:


electrical_s || with +4 votes || banner

Mod's choice:
no this time, sorry.

Tally:
1;++++
2;-
3;---
4;+
5;-
6;

Comments:
1;
#01 - love the composition and colours.
#01 - like how soft it looks. and great removal of the background.
#01 - The texture and coloring look beautiful.
#01 - good texture use, nice colours.

2;
#02 - too dark colouring and I think that duplication isn't good for this icon.

3;
#03 - Way overly sharpened.
#03 - it's over sharpened and has a crop that doesn't make her look pretty.
#03 - don't like the crop, pale colours, not very good quality.

4;
#04 - nice cropping and colouring.

5;
#05 - strange crop, dark icon, bad contrast.