results session 3: challenge 5

[loving_w]

Elimination:


butsojealous || with -2 votes
I'm so sorry, hun! :(

People's choice:
no, because of tie. ^^

Mod's choice:


just_jm || banner

Tally:
1;++-
2;+
3;+-+-
4;--

Comments:
1;
+#01 - pretty colours, use of textures.
-#01 - a bit blury.
+#01 - lovely colouring and crop.

2;
+#02 - The cropping is nice, and the coloring is pretty.

3;
-#03 - too much going on, the icon is too yellow.
+#03 - за оригинальность.
-#03 - original icon but too much yellow colour.
+#03 - I love the effects of this icon.

4;
-#04 - I don't like that the picture is black in white, and I don't like the text.
-#04 - The text doesn't look the best with the icon. But, if the text wasn't there, it would be a nice icon.