Comments | animanga_lims: Animanga LIMS Round Three: CH. 14 RESULTS

garrus in animanga_lims

Animanga LIMS Round Three: CH. 14 RESULTS

Dec 02, 2007 22:15

Sorry these were late, got back from dinner late. DX

( Challenge 3-14 ELIMINATIONS )

round 3, challenge 3-14, results

Comments 9

powercorrupts December 3 2007, 04:26:51 UTC

Oh well. I really liked my icon, but that's how these things roll.

Crits for #1, please.

eliminate December 3 2007, 04:33:26 UTC

askdlj I thought your icon was the best.

anyway, I wanted to let you know that your username is A+++++++

powercorrupts December 3 2007, 04:37:31 UTC

Thank you! ♥

xD thanks!

eliminate December 3 2007, 04:38:30 UTC

you're welcome! :3

arishokku December 3 2007, 05:15:00 UTC

Not surprised xD. I made it this far so I'm kinda happy :D
Thanks!
Crits for #3, please :)

darkenedsakura December 3 2007, 06:01:48 UTC

Ack, almost out. 8D Crits for #6 please?

undini December 3 2007, 15:48:02 UTC

Congrats to PC winning icon =).

Crits please ~

cynicalsnark December 3 2007, 22:29:12 UTC

Wow it was really close this week.

Comments and Crits for #4 please? Unscreened.

Un-screened garrus December 3 2007, 23:02:12 UTC

POSITIVE
+ (no comment)
+ I like the composition and vibrant colors.
+ Lovely composition, the bars on the side are well done.
+ I adore the colour and crop on this one; it's been a while since we've had a nice non-centered image~
+ I love the crispness and the rich colours, a nicely balanced icon.
+ (no comment)

NEGATIVE
- while the use of kanji (?) is interesting, it overpowers the icon and the image seems too crowded.
- I like the idea, but I don't like the cropping or the text placement. Normally I like tinytext, but not in this situation, or rather, I think it's poorly executed.