skulljokelol Do they have Shinen?: Yes Can Atsuki read their mind?: Maybe? I'll explain below Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
I actually had to give this a lot of though. Brook may be dead, but he's actually very much alive at the same time. The main function of his Devil Fruit power was to revive him after death and give him a second chance at life, so it's implied that had he been able to find his body sooner, he would've been flesh and blood living just like anyone else. He does have a soul, and it is specifically stated in the manga that he's not a zombie.
Between that and how emotive of a character he is, I think he would have Shinen. I also think Atsuki could read his mind, but you can determine the difficulty, if you wish. I'm still not quite sure how that might work. As far as difficulty goes, if being dead makes it harder, I'd think it could still be done. If it isn't an issue, than things just may not quite make sense - Brook's not completely there in the head, after all.
Thank you for the thought out comment there I was wondering about him. ♥
Off-hand here... if it states he's not a zombie, has a soul, and is revived I think it's possible that Atsuki should be able to pick up something (after all he was able to "read the mind" of the recently deceased, so this could be the same principle) but it would be a theoretically risky move for him given Brook's uh, relatively close proximity to the concept of "death."
Not to mention given his experiences with reading dead people - and Brook looks pretty dead, actually - he might actually be weary to even try, pfft.
Well the Rune is inorganic so I doubt he can read it's mind, but given that it's a uh... it's like coexistence, right? It might feel similar (albeit much less malicious) to someone infested with Silent to him.
loyalotter Do they have Shinen?: yes Can Atsuki read their mind?: Yes Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
halfbloodpotion Do they have Shinen?: That would depend - we should probably talk this one out. Actually, he probably does, but he's such a good Occlumens, he can block what he's really feeling and supplant what he wants other people to think he's feeling. So, likely, Atsuki could discover some things, but I'll have to be specific about what can be determined and what is real. Can Atsuki read their mind?: see above Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No? I'm not certain. I'll say no, though.
Ah yes, Snape. You know I had been thinking about that one for some time as I was typing this post up. I think for when it comes to dealing with the guy directly almost certainly Saijo would be in for the same thing most people do - getting faked readings and such. The issue which comes up though is that it's technically SIG-MA (Signum Anima) in that it touches on both the mind and (rofl) soul. Plus it's less that he reads mind that he takes a bit of someone's mind and puts it into himself to read it so uh
( ... )
Okay, that makes sense. You're totally welcome to feel that there's something very weird about him, especially (if the topic ever comes up) regarding Lily. One of those "wtf there's something he's not telling me, what the hell is this feeling?" kind of things, if that makes sense. Especially since his feelings for her are so deep and conflicted. The conflicting emotions are all very, very strong, so it'd be like getting overwhelmed with about ten thousand different things at once, too, so that your guy might get confused rather than anything specific.
Mostly Snape's very in control in everything except things involving Lily |D and since I'm trying to eventually have that become known, it's perfectly cool with me if you pick up that something's weird. Yeah, I wasn't thinking so, but best to check |D
Xigbar, Vexen and Lexaeus are Nobodies, so skipping them.
andallaretrue Do they have Shinen?: Yep Can Atsuki read their mind?: Probably just the surface stuff Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? She might be able to on account of being a goddess? idk
ranksinmistlore Do they have Shinen?: Yes Can Atsuki read their mind?: Just the surface stuff Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
knighted_lion Do they have Shinen?: Yes, but he has a tendency to clamp down on his emotions what good. Can Atsuki read their mind?: Sure Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
gamblinghigh Do they have Shinen?: Yes Can Atsuki read their mind?: Go right ahead Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? Nope
Comments 193
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Yes
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
gotmebones
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Go for it
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
chie_not_chuck
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Yes
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
Reply
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Maybe? I'll explain below
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
I actually had to give this a lot of though. Brook may be dead, but he's actually very much alive at the same time. The main function of his Devil Fruit power was to revive him after death and give him a second chance at life, so it's implied that had he been able to find his body sooner, he would've been flesh and blood living just like anyone else. He does have a soul, and it is specifically stated in the manga that he's not a zombie.
Between that and how emotive of a character he is, I think he would have Shinen. I also think Atsuki could read his mind, but you can determine the difficulty, if you wish. I'm still not quite sure how that might work. As far as difficulty goes, if being dead makes it harder, I'd think it could still be done. If it isn't an issue, than things just may not quite make sense - Brook's not completely there in the head, after all.
Reply
Off-hand here... if it states he's not a zombie, has a soul, and is revived I think it's possible that Atsuki should be able to pick up something (after all he was able to "read the mind" of the recently deceased, so this could be the same principle) but it would be a theoretically risky move for him given Brook's uh, relatively close proximity to the concept of "death."
Not to mention given his experiences with reading dead people - and Brook looks pretty dead, actually - he might actually be weary to even try, pfft.
Reply
Reply
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Maybe just surface thoughts.
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
boranda_hawk
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Sure
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
...Considering Luc's soul is entwined with his wind rune, there might be some difference or something with mind reading there? I'm not sure.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Do they have Shinen?: yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Yes
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
halfbloodpotion
Do they have Shinen?: That would depend - we should probably talk this one out. Actually, he probably does, but he's such a good Occlumens, he can block what he's really feeling and supplant what he wants other people to think he's feeling. So, likely, Atsuki could discover some things, but I'll have to be specific about what can be determined and what is real.
Can Atsuki read their mind?: see above
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No? I'm not certain. I'll say no, though.
Reply
Reply
Okay, that makes sense. You're totally welcome to feel that there's something very weird about him, especially (if the topic ever comes up) regarding Lily. One of those "wtf there's something he's not telling me, what the hell is this feeling?" kind of things, if that makes sense. Especially since his feelings for her are so deep and conflicted. The conflicting emotions are all very, very strong, so it'd be like getting overwhelmed with about ten thousand different things at once, too, so that your guy might get confused rather than anything specific.
Mostly Snape's very in control in everything except things involving Lily |D and since I'm trying to eventually have that become known, it's perfectly cool with me if you pick up that something's weird.
Yeah, I wasn't thinking so, but best to check |D
Reply
andallaretrue
Do they have Shinen?: Yep
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Probably just the surface stuff
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? She might be able to on account of being a goddess? idk
ranksinmistlore
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Just the surface stuff
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
knighted_lion
Do they have Shinen?: Yes, but he has a tendency to clamp down on his emotions what good.
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Sure
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? No
gamblinghigh
Do they have Shinen?: Yes
Can Atsuki read their mind?: Go right ahead
Can they see Atsuki's mind-tentacles? Nope
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment