9.1 Voting

[sidhex3]

Unfortunately, rebelstrike21 and infanta_teribla did not submit their entries by the deadline and are disqualified.

Peer's Choice winner will be the comm's new default icon.

Rules:
- You will be voting for ONE lesser quality icons and for ONE best icon. Vote according to quality and technique, not personal preference. If there is a problem with your vote, I will ask you to

Comments

[czarnalukrecja]

LEAST:
#10 - the icon is too bright and fuzzy and the texture doesn't really fit it...

BEST:
#08 - very nice coloring and crop

[juniorfan29]

LEAST:
#007 - The coloring is very unattractive too look at, it's too bright and too yellow, and the color choice for the text is very hard on the eyes.

BEST:
#004 - Very clear, visually appealing, and I like how the coloring makes the flower 'pop'.

[overevery]

LEAST:
#10 - too many textures for 1 icon

BEST:
#03 - nice crop and shape

[sidhex3]

can you give a bit more explanation to your 'least' vote please? as it stands, i can't accept it.

[overevery]

ok.
& textures overlap the icon

[rubberduckgrrl]

LEAST:
#010 - Colors very washed out and the "light streaks"? across the front are odd. They don't seem to follow a typical glare pattern.

BEST:
#006 - Good color contrast. The sharp focus in the front along with the deep pink really pop against the background. The purple sky complements the flower nicely.

[endearest]

LEAST:
#07 - neither the text placement or font colour compliment the icon. The contrast is also quite high, making the icon appear quite sharp.

BEST:
#08 - lovely crop + soft colouring.