9.2 Voting

[sidhex3]

Skipping: setentpet and cyanidexbeauty

Rules:
- You will be voting for ONE lesser quality icons and for ONE best icon. Vote according to quality and technique, not personal preference. Please be as specific as possible. Vague and/or ambiguous comments will only force me to ask you for clarification. ;) If there is a problem with your vote, I will ask you to change it

Comments

[setentpet]

how can i vote against any of these??

LEAST:
#01 - The subject is going to be cute no matter what but in this icon the background texture does not flow well with the icon.

BEST:
#05 - Nicely cropped.

[narniacmr]

LEAST:
#01 - The icon is slightly washed out and the frame and text make the icon too busy.

BEST:
#04 - The icon is nicely sharpened and the text flows well with the colors and placement.

[endearest]

LEAST:
#07 the overall blue tone of icon is very overpower combined wit the light texture + black lines.

BEST:
#04 - great pun + cool colouring

[rubberduckgrrl]

LEAST:
#01 - The colored background is distracting, and the font choice could be better as I am unable to read the name of the bear. The photo appears washed out, too many details missing.

BEST:
#03 - While 003 and 005 chose the same photo, I really like what 003 did with it. The colors are good and the crop is great, all while keeping the fur details showing.

[nodazzle]

LEAST:
#07 - The colouring is too blue and needs more contrast... and then there is this random red blob that steals your attention away from the subject.

BEST:
#06 - I love the quote but also think the picture has nice colour and contrast. :)

Thanks for the vote at xf_lims :D