Comments | anything_lims: 8.10: Finals voting!

sidhex3 in anything_lims

8.10: Finals voting!

Jul 06, 2009 15:26

Here we are with the finals voting! Good luck to the participants!

Voting Rules:
- You will be voting for ONE favourite icon from EACH SET. You will also vote for ONE favourite icon OVERALL (this will be used only in the event of a tie ( Read more... )

8.10

Comments 21

anonymous July 6 2009, 23:04:48 UTC

sidhex3 July 7 2009, 00:38:38 UTC

reasons for all votes are required. ;)

rebelstrike21 July 7 2009, 00:56:34 UTC

Oops -- sorry!

FAVOURITE PART A:
#2 - Great texture use.
FAVOURITE PART B:
#5 - Good text placement and coloring.
FAVOURITE PART C:
#9 - Good text use and contrast.
FAVOURITE PART D:
#10 - Vivid, striking coloring.
FAVOURITE OVERALL:
#2 - Most original composition and wonderful, soft coloring.

misskitty_79 July 6 2009, 23:16:34 UTC

FAVOURITE PART A:
#01 : (fits the subject most accurately - nice colouring)
FAVOURITE PART B:
#04 : (best crop, though there is quite a lot of white space that seems wasteful)
FAVOURITE PART C:
#08 : (most dynamic crop & best contrast balance)
FAVOURITE PART D:
#12 : (really makes you believe that there's wind moving the blades of the windmill/wheat)

I am unclear as to whether or not we're meant to be voting for my favourite SET, or simply my favourite ICON? If we're looking as SETS, am we to assume that each column's images are created by the same icon maker.
Because of this, I have not yet voted in the FAVOURITE OVERALL category.
Please let me know!

sidhex3 July 7 2009, 00:37:28 UTC

ONE favourite icon OVERALL

;)

misskitty_79 July 7 2009, 00:51:58 UTC

Thanks for clearing that one up. :)

FAVOURITE OVERALL:
#11 : (dynamic colouring & crop. I'd have been tempted to add text, but I don't remember whether or not that was permitted according to the rules!)

setentpet July 6 2009, 23:27:37 UTC

FAVOURITE PART A:
#1 : very nice coloring.
FAVOURITE PART B:
#4 : nice crop, crop and use of text.
FAVOURITE PART C:
#8 : nicely contrasted.
FAVOURITE PART D:
#11 : lovely coloring.
FAVOURITE OVERALL:
#1 : just very nice coloring, makes it really stand out.

sra33 July 7 2009, 02:18:14 UTC

FAVOURITE PART A:
#03 : Nice cropping and good overall coloring

FAVOURITE PART B:
0#5 : this icon had the best coloring, and a very good crop

FAVOURITE PART C:
#08 : Good overall presentation

FAVOURITE PART D:
#12 : nice use of effect, making the icon really pop

FAVOURITE OVERALL:
#01 : A very vibrant icon, nicely done. :)

Not a vote!! ender839 July 7 2009, 03:39:52 UTC

Just wanted to say that all the icons submitted look fantastic and that I'm honored to be in such excellent company for the finals!

Congrats to incognito323 and karlakaine!