(Untitled)

Mar 25, 2009 21:14

This is pretty much what I thought of the BSG finale/fourth season, though I myself did not write it with the sole exception of ( the following )

Leave a comment

Comments 2

(The comment has been removed)

artricia March 26 2009, 20:41:23 UTC
Yeah, I'm not sure it's all as clear-cut as this "Jeff" guy makes it sound. And I think you're spot-on about the differences in deaths for soldiers. (My dad, for instance, couldn't deal with the death of his dog, and couldn't deal with the fact that he couldn't deal with it because he *had* dealt with so much in Vietnam.) Maybe it's a matter of amount/focus? I mean, we've been hammered over the head with his grief this past season, and haven't gotten enough else that feels . . . good. Maybe they just couldn't write this kind of thing as well? I don't know -- I just know that it didn't fully work for me ( ... )

Reply

encyclops March 26 2009, 22:48:00 UTC
Generally I'm in the "hated it" camp. I've written a couple of posts on it at encyclops.com if you're at all interested in my take. I like it less now the more I've thought about it, unfortunately; today I don't know if I'd say it "ended well."

I agree with pretty much every point that guy made, even though I know not everyone does.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up