Round 2 aftermath: Critique Post
Here's the post-round-two critique! You're welcome to post icons from this challenge, but if you have other icons laying about that you'd like critiqued it's fine to comment with them too.
- You can only post FIVE icons for critique at a time. You can post more after your first five have been critiqued by at least ONE person.
- You can only post YOUR OWN work.
- Anyone can post a critique, but if the maintainers find you being unnecessarily snarky/hurtful with your comments, you will no longer be allowed to post critiques.
- Remember, all critiques should be CONSTRUCTIVE. This means they should feature ways to improve an icon. "I don't like the text" is bad; "The text is dark and hard to read" is better.
- Please include the program you use to make graphics in your comment. Some of us know programs better than others and this makes it easier to provide feedback.
- If you want your comment & its replies screened, just say so. Remember, comments are not screened by default!
--If you post icons please consider commenting to critique others' work as well! Giving critique is a great way to learn how to look at your own icons objectively.
- ALL OPINIONS ARE SUBJECTIVE. Everyone has their own tastes, and they are only telling you how THEY think you should improve your icon. You do not need to treat these critiques as above reproach and correct in all ways.
Questions? Comments? Ask away!
- You can only post FIVE icons for critique at a time. You can post more after your first five have been critiqued by at least ONE person.
- You can only post YOUR OWN work.
- Anyone can post a critique, but if the maintainers find you being unnecessarily snarky/hurtful with your comments, you will no longer be allowed to post critiques.
- Remember, all critiques should be CONSTRUCTIVE. This means they should feature ways to improve an icon. "I don't like the text" is bad; "The text is dark and hard to read" is better.
- Please include the program you use to make graphics in your comment. Some of us know programs better than others and this makes it easier to provide feedback.
- If you want your comment & its replies screened, just say so. Remember, comments are not screened by default!
--If you post icons please consider commenting to critique others' work as well! Giving critique is a great way to learn how to look at your own icons objectively.
- ALL OPINIONS ARE SUBJECTIVE. Everyone has their own tastes, and they are only telling you how THEY think you should improve your icon. You do not need to treat these critiques as above reproach and correct in all ways.
Questions? Comments? Ask away!