1. AGREED. Severus Snape would be better off alive. Living would be his penance for the sins he has committed. I'm sure Snape actually wanted to die on some level, but to make him live would just continue the torture on his lovely dark soul. :D
( ... )
I just finished reading the book kitty cat, if the fake was real did you like it? I found the book to be incredible... and it looks like I have to take back complains 3 and 6. ._. I can't believe she managed to do all that.
It's a hero's journey. The hero may sojourn in the lands of the dead, but rarely does he ever stay there. Killing Harry off at the end and having Neville finish off Voldemort would be equivalent to... the Emperor killing Luke Skywalker in Return of the Jedi and Han Solo popping up out of nowhere to finish him and Darth Vader. It just wouldn't work on that mythic level.
I see your point. It's valid. But think how much cooler it would have been when Han Solo won in the end, especially considering Mark Hamill's monotone acting ability :P
In all honesty though, I did like star wars the way it was, and I think I'm liking book 7 the way it is. It's just not very fannon friendly, and we've been writing the final battle for a long while now.
Comments 9
Reply
OH.
HELL.
The fake is REAL.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
In all honesty though, I did like star wars the way it was, and I think I'm liking book 7 the way it is. It's just not very fannon friendly, and we've been writing the final battle for a long while now.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment