Leave a comment

Comments 10

misses_turner September 8 2009, 06:38:24 UTC
lesser quality
01 - The black border is distracting and cropping seems a little random
02 - I think the cropping is too close for this picture. Billy's mouth and nose seem giant

favorite
07 - (reason optional)

Reply


setentpet September 10 2009, 01:55:30 UTC
VOTING FORM:
lesser quality
#6 - Definately a interesting close crop but it could use some definate sharpening.
#1 - The texture use, I am guessing, dulls the icon's coloring and washes it out a little.

favorite
#5

Reply


vapor September 10 2009, 02:49:49 UTC
lesser quality
01 -- it looks like a cloud texture was used, but it makes parts of the icon seem washed out and overall lacking contrast; also, the black bar along the left side is distracting
06 -- coloring is too pink and icon is pixelated

favorite
05 -- great crop, beatiful cropping, and perfect sharpening

Reply


megalicious September 10 2009, 04:20:52 UTC
lesser quality
#1 - The bar on the left side is unflattering and a bit distracting - it's too dark, and my eye goes straight to it, instead of Billie's face.
#3 - The repetition at the top is... odd. The texture use in the background could be better, perhaps if it was a solid instead of a diagonal pattern. Her face is a bit too sharpened, as well.

favorite
#2

Reply


nodazzle September 10 2009, 05:11:05 UTC
lesser quality
06 - The colouring is alright - though it's a little on the pink side which sort of enhances the blotchiness of her skin/makeup. Also, overall the icon seems a tad undersharpened - probably because it was rotated a bit.
04 - I like the colouring BUT it doesn't work with this crop because her shirt is so dark but her facial features so washed out by comparison.

favorite
05 - exceptional clarity and contrast.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up