4x12

Jun 28, 2008 21:19

On the whole, er, wow, but some major problems - RTD reusing a plot device from last year ("let's all pray link up our phones to find the Doctor") - and some really ropy CGI ( Read more... )

doctor who, telly

Leave a comment

Comments 7

myfirstkitchen June 28 2008, 20:47:50 UTC
Agreed on most of that, especially the death - Donna too obvious, Martha's in the TW radio thing and I expect S3/the TW miniseries, SJA S2 is filming and Jack can't die. Except I enjoyed S2 of TW. I do like that Ianto came across as the pouty bratty clingy idiot that he is, though. Janto shippers drive me insane.

Reply


surliminal June 28 2008, 22:13:03 UTC
Didn't you think it kind of icky like how Gwen and Ianto were Jack's two wifes waiting for him to come home? I don't even know if that's a homophobic comment but it's just an anti-schmaltz comment, grrr!

Reply

blue_condition June 28 2008, 22:14:44 UTC
I'm amazed someone as cool and pansexual and irresistible as Captain Jack even wants to keep a Welsh fishwife and a stereotypical poofter around. ;)

Reply


moral_vacuum June 28 2008, 22:23:29 UTC
BTW: I note that one of the missing planets was Calufrax, which was of course The Pirate Planet.

Reply

blue_condition June 28 2008, 22:26:09 UTC
I spotted the name, knew it was an oldWho[4] planet, but couldn't remember offhand which one it was ;)

Reply

moral_vacuum June 28 2008, 22:29:57 UTC
I've always been a Keys To Time fanboy. Probably because I was in love with Mary Tamm.

(Hence noticing that the The Stones of Blood owes a hell of a lot to The Maneater of Surrey Green in The Avengers).

Reply


ravensthorpe June 29 2008, 20:05:26 UTC
I think Bernard should get his own series. Everyone is running about like headless chickens and he goes after a Dalek (or differently-corporeal Skarovian as we should say these days) with a paintball gun.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up