Bioshock Infinte

Apr 01, 2013 01:53

So this is going to be spoilertastic but i'll put all that stuff behind a cut ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 5

hethatishere April 1 2013, 16:19:02 UTC
I agree that the game brought up social issues but didn't discuss/critique them in a way that I wanted or expected. There is one conversation where Elizabeth asks why there are separate bathrooms for Whites and Non-Whites and you answer passively. She responds basically saying it is silly and unnecessarily complicated. That was perfect, the only problem is the game is light on commentary about a world of extreme haves and have-nots, simply leaving you to your own reactions ( ... )

Reply

brigid April 1 2013, 22:59:54 UTC
one thing that bothered me about the game and how it touched on social issues (especially racism) was how it sort of would say "wow this society is racist, what a bunch of dicks" and then turn around and throw Chen Lin at us, who was a pretty bad caricature of an Asian American. That was a huge WTF moment for me. Same with the drunk angry Irish people in Shanty Town who you are supposed to simultaneously feel bad for & kill off once they get pissed at you for stealing from them (which afaik you have to do? unless there was a way to sneak around them to get the vigor enhancer thing ( ... )

Reply

brigid April 1 2013, 23:35:24 UTC
i swear i am not trying to troll you, you really are one of the few hardcore bioshock fans i know so bear with me on this, but what do you think of this article? http://www.oxm.co.uk/51623/features/why-bioshock-infinites-ending-doesnt-work/

i haven't gotten through the whole thing but i love the line, "i like this game so much i'm trying to make this work" because that is sort of how i feel. i also love the fact that the game has this many people thinking and rationalizing over the plot, i really do....though i wish this power had been used for good and had us bitching about Objectivism again ;)

Reply

hethatishere April 2 2013, 02:38:42 UTC
Well, I literally spent all evening on a point-by-point rebuttal of that article right down to creating a bloody diagram:


... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up