Leonard came home an hour later. He didn’t seem happy.
‘Huh’ was all he said.
Sheldon thought for a moment, trying to figure what the ‘huh’ meant.
‘So you guys kissed’
He almost fall down. Penny told him? Leonard was waiting for an answer.
‘Could you be more specific?’
‘For God’s sake Sheldon! It’s a simple fact! She told me! You kissed!’
He had never seen him so mad. He was having a panic attack.
‘Calm down Leonard, this is probably not that bad’
‘Not that bad? Sheldon, you kissed my girlfriend!’
He had stressed the word ‘girlfriend’ and Sheldon couldn’t help but think how wrong it sounded.
‘From all the people I know, you’re the last one I would have think of a threat!’
That was really insulting. But he said nothing. Why did she tell him? It was supposed to be a secret.
‘Leonard, I assure you that it wasn’t something I planned. What exactly happened when I left Penny’s apartment?’
‘I’ll tell you what happened’
Sheldon had just left. And she felt a great emptiness in her heart. She just wanted to be with him, talk about what happened between them. He left but he kissed her softly on her lips, his blue eyes into hers. And then she looked at Leonard, who seemed lost and sad. She said ‘I love you’ to someone who wasn’t her boyfriend. And to be more specific, to someone she never thought saying ‘I love you’ to. And yet she did and it had felt so true, so sincere, from the bottom of her heart.
‘Leonard, we need to talk’
‘Alright. About what?’
‘Us. It doesn’t work. You have to admit it. It didn’t work from the beginning but we continued anyway. And I’m not comfortable with that situation because I care about you and I don’t want to lose you’
At least that was true. But she knew him too well and he was not happy about it. He had waited for so long to be with her. That was the thing. They’ve been friends for two years, getting to know each other better. He was her best friend. And having sex with your best friend was a bad idea. A terrible idea. She had to end it before it was too late. And the main reason she couldn’t tell him was that when he kissed her, she had still the taste of Sheldon on her lips. And how much she liked it was not the right thing to say either.
‘Hold on’ he said, clearly understanding what she was implying, ‘you want to break up?’
She nodded quietly and tried to smile but he looked away in disbelief.
‘I can’t believe you!’
‘Look Leonard…I’m really sorry’
‘What happened this week-end?’
Now he was staring at her. He knew. One way or another, he knew. I kissed Sheldon. I kissed him four times. And I liked it. I have never felt so complete. Her silence was even worse apparently. His eyes were intense, blacker than she ever seen before.
‘Sheldon and I kissed’
The words just came out of her mouth and she felt a huge weight flied from her body. Leonard widened his eyes. Then he started to laugh.
‘You and Sheldon kissed?’
He didn’t believe her. How could he? It was insane. If it had been someone else than Sheldon he would have maybe believed it.
‘Yes but I promise you it’s not his fault. He didn’t even know what he was doing. I initiated the kiss and…’
‘You initiated the kiss?’ he interrupted, bewildered. He looked at the ceiling and messed his hair with his hands. Penny wanted to put a hand on his arm but he was so out of him she didn’t dare to touch him. That would make it worse.
‘Yes but only because I felt so good! It was a way of thanking him for being so nice. Like I often did before we went out!’
He remembered alright. But Sheldon?
‘So…just once?’
Penny swallowed hard. She felt like a criminal. Not once. Not two. But four!
‘No…’
The look on his face was hurting her. She hated it. Being that person. Her ex-boyfriends were jerks and now she was too. But it was Sheldon she had kissed. Not some random guy. Sheldon. The guy was a challenge. The guy who talked about things she didn’t get. The guy who didn’t kiss anyone. The guy she thought was impossible to kiss. To touch. The guy she knew for two years. The guy who wasn’t afraid of his geekyness. The guy who…She caught Leonard’s eye and she stopped to think. He deserved some answers.
‘I kissed him twice’
‘Twice?’
‘Three?’
He scoffed. He sat on her couch and put his hands on his lap. She stood still, not daring to move a slight or make a noise.
‘What does it mean?’ he asked, his eyes on the floor. He had a high-pitched voice. She sighed and put her hands on her hips.
‘I don’t know. I need to think Leonard’
He nodded absently and stood up.
‘I’ll leave you alone. I probably should talk to Sheldon. But I’ll come back tomorrow. I…need to think too…’
‘Okay…I’m so sorry about all this’
He shook his head and waved his hands. He opened her door and marched across the hall with no turning back. She sighed again and closed her door. After a while of thinking and sighing she heard someone yelling…Leonard. He was yelling at Sheldon. Oh poor Sheldon. She burst into their apartment to find Leonard walking back and forth and yelling some incomprehensive words at Sheldon, who seemed terrified and not able to say anything for his defense.
‘Sweetie…’ she said softly, caressing his arm. He widened his eyes and jumped out of surprise. Leonard turned around and shrieked.
‘Penny!’
‘Penny, now is not a good time’ Sheldon said calmly. Was he trying to protect her?
‘Sheldon, now is not a good time!’ Leonard replied sharply, looking up at him with disdain.
‘I’m sorry Leonard but you’ve been yelling for about ten minutes now and I was unable to say anything. I didn’t try to steal Penny from you. I always told you it was a bad idea to date her but you never listened’
‘Oh and now you think you’re better?’
Penny tried to protest but she wasn’t fast enough.
‘I never said something similar to that! You never listen Leonard. As you know I’m not familiar with intimate relationships. And Penny…she’s way out of my league’
He was staring at her. She shivered under his gaze and smiled lightly. How could he say that? Out of her league? That was crazy. He was a sweetie pie, though she never noticed before. He was perfectly shaped. Oh no, she lost the conversation. Leonard was still yelling but he was repeating the same word, ‘why’. And now he was looking right at her.
‘Why Penny?’
She was breathless. The tension in the room was unbearable. Sheldon was close to her and she relaxed a little. She took a deep breath.
‘Stop harassing me Leonard!’
She felt the tears coming into her eyes.
‘Penny is tired’ Sheldon said, avoiding Leonard’s gaze.
‘Why? Among all the people, why her? Why him? He’s so much smarter than me! And he’s a nut case!’
‘Okay Leonard, I’m not going to stay here and being insulted. It’s up to Penny. If she doesn’t want to date you anymore, let her. And before you start to complain and whine, I’m not implying that I’d make a good mate for her. But I can’t pretend there’s nothing changed’
Penny was speechless. She threw herself into his arms, not noticing Leonard calling out her name.
‘Group hug?’
Howard and Raj just burst out in the apartment but Raj immediately sensed the tension in the room. He whispered something to Howard who said ‘oh’.
‘This is not a group hug Howard, this is a double betrayal’ Leonard said darkly, staring at the weird couple.
‘This is not a betrayal Leonard’ Sheldon corrected, letting go off Penny, ‘this is a mark of affection. And may I recall you what you did while we were in the North Pole? This is nothing compared to that. And it’s not a revenge. But you have to admit that your relationship with Penny only relies on sex and nothing else. You now have became friends with benefits’
He couldn’t help a smirk as he finally understood the full concept of ‘friends with benefits’. Even Howard seemed surprised.
‘I feel like we missed something’ he said, addressing to Leonard.
‘You couldn’t be more right Howard. Imagine that: Sheldon and Penny made out four times and now I think Sheldon starts to understand the definition of a human being. And he chose Penny as his female’
‘I’m not a female! Leonard, this is private!’
‘Leonard, she have a point, considering…’
‘Shut up!’
‘Leave him alone!’
Howard and Raj looked at each other in disbelief. Leonard, Sheldon and Penny were breathing loud and fast, out of argument. Penny broke the silence.
‘Leonard, we’re so good at being friends. Please don’t ruin everything. I’m sure you’ll find someone so much better than me, at least someone who’s right for you. You need to be honest with yourself’
Leonard opened his mouth but closed it, thinking. She was right. They had nothing in common. And they were such good friends. He knew he had to move on with his life. He looked at Sheldon, realizing that he seemed happy. He looked at Penny, who was staring at Sheldon with so much tenderness that he couldn’t deny it. They liked each other. And it’d be funny to watch Sheldon dealing with this new social intimacy.
‘I guess’
Penny faced him with intensity, tears in her eyes. He smiled at her and held his hands. She went to hug him and Howard and Raj looked even more confused.
‘What the frack? Sheldon, do you know what’s going on?’
‘I believe so’ he replied with a grin, ‘Leonard finally understood what I’ve been trying to tell him for almost three years. And I think I’ll find myself with a all new experience. Am I correct?’
He turned to Penny, who was smiling widely at him. She let go off Leonard and came closer, step by step. Sheldon stood still, not daring to say anything. She wrapped her arms around his neck and looked deeply into his eyes.
‘I’ll never get tired of those eyes’
‘I’ll never get tired of you’
‘Damn’ Raj said, before squeaking as he realized he had spoken in front a girl.
‘Hulk and Peppermint Patty are officially a couple’ added Howard, glancing at Leonard, who was smiling too. He was ready. Ready to be happy with the perfect girl for him. Sheldon put his arms around Penny’s waist and kissed her. Yeah, she could definitely getting used to his idiosyncrasies, as long as his perfectly shaped mouth kissed hers. And once again, but this time without feeling any guilt, the world vanished, like a big bang and Penny smiled into him, ready for a crazy adventure with the guy she liked the moment she met him and who was now sure to love. And the way he was kissing her, his hands caressing her back, brushing his naked waist, made her believe he loved her too.
Sheldon was not the guy who believed in such nonsense but he had to admit that Penny was an exception, maybe since the first time he met her. And he knew, deep down, that he was listening to his heart for the very first time and he was beating for Penny. Like a bang. Who cared about their three friends, clearing their throat for them to stop. Penny dragged Sheldon back into her apartment, never breaking contact with his mouth but Sheldon lift her up. She wrapped her legs around his waist, her cheeks burning and he managed to open her door, still kissing her. Wow, Sheldon Cooper was strong. And damn good! Yep, she needed him, listening to her heart for the very first time. The heart wants what the heart wants. And her heart wanted Sheldon. No one else. As he closed the door, pulling her against it, she knew he wasn’t thinking about string theory. And he was a fast learner. And she thought for a second, repressing a laugh: Sheldon and Penny for the win. Then her mind stopped to think. And his mind stopped thinking as well, focusing only on Penny. That was it.
The End.