As you all may remember, the reopening of bsg_awards for nomms is in 4 days ((6th October)). Bearing that in mind, I have been taking suggestions under consideration and wanted to get some general feedback
( Read more... )
- NOT best coloring/best BW together! - 2 rounds for special cat sounds nice - Everyone is good, but I think overall, "most original" is the hardest to find.
I went ahead and copied and pasted your categories below and made little notes. I know, so obnoxious. lol. But I have some icontest communities as well and I love feedback, so you might appreciate this. :)
I have an awards community and sadly, I have found that people are confused by the nifty names I have given each category. feedback_awards in case you want to look at my categories. I thought they were very simple. I'm not sure what to do about this, because I think the categories need to have names.
I think allowing promo pictures in all the categories is good. Lot's of people make icons from promo pictures. Especially at the beginning of a season.
Colonial Day - Best overall icon. One of those icons that totally knocks you for six. This one is goodFlesh and Bone - Must include actors outside their BSG roles on screen only. May include promo shoots [not including episode promos for BSG, because technically they're just caps of the episode], other roles, photo shoots, award show photos, etc. This category can include multiple cast
( ... )
Comments 3
- 2 rounds for special cat sounds nice
- Everyone is good, but I think overall, "most original" is the hardest to find.
Reply
I have an awards community and sadly, I have found that people are confused by the nifty names I have given each category. feedback_awards in case you want to look at my categories. I thought they were very simple. I'm not sure what to do about this, because I think the categories need to have names.
I think allowing promo pictures in all the categories is good. Lot's of people make icons from promo pictures. Especially at the beginning of a season.
Colonial Day - Best overall icon. One of those icons that totally knocks you for six. This one is goodFlesh and Bone - Must include actors outside their BSG roles on screen only. May include promo shoots [not including episode promos for BSG, because technically they're just caps of the episode], other roles, photo shoots, award show photos, etc. This category can include multiple cast ( ... )
Reply
and, my opinion is that nomming actor/promo icons in all of the catergories might be better
I hope not too many catergories get culled :(
I'm rather fond of them :)
Reply
Leave a comment