ROUND THREE: CHALLENGE ONE: RESULTS

[carnimirie]

Sorry for the delay, we had a tie for both elimination AND people's choice this week. (Also, my arms are dead from my swim class DX).


ELIMINATED:

whitelilies22 (-5)


PEOPLE'S CHOICE:
fiendie (+3)


MOD'S CHOICE:
ryzhaya_tapka


This icon has a nice whimsical atmosphere to it. I love especially the use of text here; it really adds to the mood.

tally:
#1: + + + = +3
#2: + + - = +1
#3: - + - - - - = -4
#4: - + + + - = +1
#5: - - - - - = -5
#6: - + + + = +2
#7: - + = 0
#8: + + - + = +2
- FOR NEGATIVE VOTES, + FOR POSITIVE

• If either choice icon winner would like a banner, feel free to request one here! I'll be making all winners' banners for the community.
• If you would like to know your comments, please comment here with your icon number and state whether you would like your comments screened or unscreened.
• If there's an icon from this challenge you would like to use, please ask the icon maker beforehand! I will unscreen the submission comments, if there are no objections from the participants.

Challenge 02 shall be posted soon. Don't forget to get your icon in by this Saturday TBA!