Rush's account is currently expired so the choices for him may be sub-optimal.
0. CURRENT DEFAULT ICON
1. NEWEST ICON
Graham hasn't had real new icons in forever. I am not sure I actually like that one of Soul still, and haven't used it. Raven's are all pretty much the same age but I missed uploading that one in the first batch.
2. OLDEST ICON
3. HAPPIEST ICON
I am defining happiest here as "sincerely happy" rather than "looking gleeful."
4. SADDEST ICON
Cheating for Medusa. I have also used that Raven icon in only not-sad contexts so far. >_>
5. ANGRIEST ICON
6. SEXIEST ICON
7. CUTEST ICON
8. ICON WITH THE HIGHEST POWER LEVEL
9. MOST FREQUENTLY USED ICON
10. ICON YOU DON'T GET TO USE ENOUGH
11. WE'RE GOING TO CANDY MOUNTAIN, CHARLIE
12. OTP
13. ICON WITH YOUR FAVORITE KEYWORDS
Rush's, Soul's, and Raven's are all song lyrics, so the ones I like best are the ones where they match up to the icon amusingly.