Title: Dude, You're Huge
Part: 2/?
Author: chordykins
Spoilers: up to Season Two, Episode Four - "Duets"
Summary: Finn approaches Sam about singing with Kurt, and one thing leads to another.
Pairing: Finn/Sam
Rating: NC-17
Words: 2,672
Sam pulled up outside Finn’s house, turning off the engine and just stopping everything. He was nervous, more nervous than he has ever been. He was about to have his first time ever with one of his only friends. Sam was completely freaking out, but before he could even stop himself from shaking Finn was already at his car door swinging it open for him. Finn didn’t look nervous at all. Actually he had a quite excited grin on his face. Sam didn’t know if Finn was a virgin too but by the look on his face you wouldn’t assume it.
“Dude, are you okay?” Finn asked, noticing the raging panic on Sam’s face as he stepped out of his car wearing the same clothes as earlier.
The blonde was a bit out of it, in a haze of sorts, he didn’t know what was going on around him. He barely even heard Finn speak, but when he saw the confused look he was receiving, it was as if his brain caught up with everything. “Uh, yeah sorry. Just a bit out of it, huge Avatar debate in film club.” He wasn’t lying, someone wrongly challenged him on the Na’Vi language and paid for it in shame.
“Uh, okay?” Finn honestly didn’t care, the only reason he saw the movie was because Quinn forced him to go with her and he knows by now not to piss her off. “Come in, I bought some food. You like Doritos right?”
Finally smiling at the mention of food, Sam’s smile returned and he answered suspiciously. “Yeah, how did you know?”
“I saw you devour almost 3 family size bags at lunch the other day.” Finn laughed, ushering Sam through his front door and up the stairs.
Walking up the stairs behind him, Sam kept his gaze on how Finn’s jeans constricted around his ass when he stepped up another step. “You watch me each lunch?” He teased.
Catching Sam’s wandering eyes, Finn’s mouth curled into a half-smile. “I saw that, and yes sometimes I can’t help myself.” Admitting his somewhat creepy obsession with the boy who now took a seat on his brand new king size bed.
“Well duh, I’m hot. Look at these babies.” Returning to his normal dorky self, Sam raised his shirt slightly, showing off his perfect abs before quickly pulling it down again before Finn’s reaching hand could touch them. “Nuh-uh, not yet.”
“Hey, no fair! You can’t just show me those and not let me touch them. Seriously, that’s just cruel.” He laughed as he sat down close to Sam, so close their legs were touching. Finn leant in to kiss him, his body turning slightly before Sam’s hand pressed his back. “What? I thought we were -“
“No we are.” Sam broke Finn off mid-sentence, distancing them slightly. “We just need to talk first. I need to tell you something. I, um, I’m a virgin.” He spoke quickly, his head sinking as if he were ashamed or just scared of how Finn would react.
Finn was shocked, he watched as Sam sunk his head and he felt so guilty. He pushed him into this without even asking if it was okay. “Oh Sam, I’m sorry I shouldn’t have forced this on you. If you don’t want to have sex we don’t have to, there’s other stuff we can do.” Sam raised his head but didn’t speak. “If it helps, I’ve never ever been with a guy. I’ve only ever slept with Santana but turns out she loves Brittany, so I guess that doesn’t count. I didn’t feel anything. That’s when I thought I might be into guys. And then there was the time I got hard watching Puck showering. But I’ve never done anything about it, not until you walked in with your gorgeous lips and ab-ulous body.”
Sam was smiling, a blush rising to his cheeks. “I want to have sex, and with you. I’m just nervous I guess. I’ve never even seen a guy naked, well out of the locker rooms. And you kind of fixed my first kiss with a guy so…”
“Well, only if you’re sure. We can figure it out together.” Smiling back at Sam, Finn didn’t realize how much this meant to him - to both of them - until now. “We’ll go as slow as you need.”
“Thank you, Finn.” Sam brushed his hand against Finn’s thigh, using free hand to pull Finn on top of him and allowing their lips to finally reunite.
Finn navigated himself, positioning himself just right so he could press himself against Sam. The kiss itself was slow and lasting, but hard. Then Finn began to take charge, swiping his tongue against Sam’s luscious lips ever so slightly until his mouth allowed him entrance.
Sam began to moan against Finn, his tongue fighting against the larger boys for dominance. He didn’t know what he was doing, but it felt good and Finn wasn’t complaining so he kept at it. Starting to get the feel for what he was doing, and for Finn’s body, Sam rolled over so he was on top and straddling Finn’s bucking hips. Protesting against their kiss ending, Finn tried to pull Sam down but failed as his hands were grasped by the blonde boy.
“Sam, what are you - oh.” Finn couldn’t even finish speaking as his eyes closed and his breath quickened even more as Sam slowly, teasing Finn, slid his shirt over his head and exposing those god given abs Finn longed for.
Not giving Sam a fighting chance, the taller boy raised himself and sucked one of Sam’s nipples into his mouth, eliciting a breathy moan. Rolling them over again, Finn took control and began to kiss down Sam’s neck, loving the feel of the boy’s hands on the back of head. Finn kissed down the perfect chest, teasing his left nipple as he brushed his hands down the length of Sam’s torso.
Finally reaching Sam’s abs, Finn paid each and every one a little attention before beginning to unbuckle Sam’s difficult belt until Sam stopped moan and pulled away.
“Wait.” The blonde boy panted, looking down at a confused Finn. Sam’s mouth hung open, loud heavy breaths sounding through the silent room.
Finn didn’t speak, he let go of the belt and pulled himself further up the bed before continuing to kiss Sam’s neck, sucking on the warm flesh.
“Finn, please… just.” He was pushing at Finn’s head, trying to move from under the larger boy who just wouldn’t let up and carried on biting slightly at his neck. “Finn!”
He looked at Sam in shock and bewilderment as the boy’s shout echoed through the room. “What’s wrong?” He asked in an almost whisper. “Am I squashing you? Santana used to say I squashed her. Is it because I bit you? I mean you sounded like you liked it. Sam, say something.” Finn pulled back from Sam and rested on his elbow next to him, gazing at him, one hand remaining to graze the exposed abdomen.
“No, no you weren’t squashing me. I did. I liked it. I just need a second or two, this is just so -“
“-Overwhelming?” Finishing Sam’s sentence, Finn smiled. He understood what he was trying to say. “I’m sorry, I just want you so much right now.”
Licking his lips, Sam finally returned Finn’s gaze and smiled. “I want you too, more than you know but if you didn’t stop I was seriously about to blow my load in my jeans.” He admitted shamelessly and with a laugh.
“Oh right, well I guess we could take a second.” Finn trailed his finger up and down Sam’s chest continuously, just liking that he could just touch him whenever and wherever. “I guess we do need to figure out how we’re going to do this. I mean who’s doing who?”
“Don’t worry, I already decided. I want you to fuck me, Finn.” He spoke so calmly, like he had just ordered a happy meal and coke, but Finn’s reaction was to merely take a deep breath because the friction of his dick against Sam’s leg combined with the dirty talk coming from that amazing mouth could totally get him off in no time. “Finn, are you listening? I said,” Sam leaned forwards and pressed his lips against Finn’s hear and whispered, “I want you to fuck me.”
Shuddering, Finn wasted no time and returned his wet lips to Sam’s neck and bathed in Sam’s very audible reaction. His hands slid down the warm body beneath him, and went straight back to the belt he was working on earlier. He really needed to get Sam naked and release the aching beast that lived in Sam’s underwear because judging by the bulge; he was most definitely packing some serious heat.
Managed to undo the belt, Finn almost ripped the jeans from Sam’s writhing body to reveal the straining in the now even tighter underwear. Grazing his hand over the rock hard dick, Sam arched to his touch moaning a bunch of incoherent words as he did so. Finn didn’t waste any time, and pulled the boxers down and watched in awe as Sam’s large member slapped against his abs.
Finn just sat there, completely dressed and completely hard as he looked at the naked body he had been picturing for weeks. His warm hands rubbed up Sam’s inner thighs causing his legs to open wider. This is where Finn began to panic. He had no idea what he was doing. He watched a video on this but as perfect as Sam is, the dummy on the video looked completely different.
“Finn, please. I need you in me, now.” Sam begged as his own hand went to reach for his dick, but Finn definitely didn’t want this ending too soon and stopped him.
“Don’t, I want this to last as long as possible.” Which won’t be very long if you keep moaning my name like that. Finn leaned up to Sam’s face and kissed him shortly before pulling the bottle of lube he rested on the bed side table. “Tell me if I hurt you okay?” Finn whispered against his neck.
Upon seeing what Finn was about to do, Sam smiled and his face filled with ecstasy. “Do you want me to do it?” He asked, looking to Finn’s completely confused face, almost a little scared. Sam had never done this, even to himself but he didn’t want to let Finn do something he was nervous about.
“Please, I mean. I just don’t know how to do anything.” Finn offered the lube to Sam and then just stared as the blond boy coated his fingers in the gel like substance. A gasp escaped his mouth as he watched Sam’s fingers rub against his hole, his dick throbbing against his jeans. He really needed to take them off, but he couldn’t tear his eyes away from the single digit now slowly entering into Sam’s body.
Finn’s eyes flickered up to Sam’s scrunched up face upon hearing a long moan, but it wasn’t long before he continued to watch as Sam fingered himself for him. Finn almost came on the spot as Sam slid another finger in, watching his ass grind down onto both of the fingers, and hearing the continuous moans.
Sam felt amazing, knowing he was turning Finn on even more only made him want to do it even more. It was weird, like his fingers shouldn’t be there but it didn’t hurt and it definitely wasn’t as bad as he thought it might be but then he couldn’t imagine how it would feel with Finn inside of him.
“Finn, I’m ready… “ Sam managed in between moans. “Why are you dressed?”
Without a word, Finn jumped off the bed and pulled his shirt over his head and yanked his jeans and boxers straight down. Forgetting his insecurities, Finn continued to watch as Sam fucked himself down on his fingers. He stroked himself lazily, knowing he shouldn’t but he needed to. Grabbed a condom he quickly rolled it on, and squirted a massive amount of lube on his cock. Leaning in between Sam’s legs, he kissed him softly and whispered, “Come on, Sam. Let me fuck you. You look so hot right now you don’t even know.”
Sam’s only reaction was to remove his fingers with a gasp and then to finally reply to Finn with only a kiss.
Finn took that as the go ahead and slowly pushed the head of his dick against Sam’s wet and open hole. He continued to kiss Sam; he figured it would be best to distract him. Continuing to press into Sam, Finn pulled from the kiss and moaned, almost matching Sam’s begging. “Oh my god, Sam. You’re so….” Sam didn’t let him finish, and Finn couldn’t stop himself from pushing all the way in suddenly causing both of them to moan throughout the kiss.
Sam’s hips began to grind down against Finn when the movement stopped, Finn was worried he hurt him but apparently not. He began slowly pulling out, trying to control himself. He was so close, just the warm and tightness of Sam around him was enough. He didn’t even need to move. But he refrained, thinking of all the mail men in Lima just to get him through.
They began a steady rhythm of thrusting, Sam against Finn and Finn into Sam. It’s lucky no one was home because their moaning combined, Sam practically shouting Finn’s name, could definitely attract unwanted attention.
“Finn, I’m so close. Finn, please harder. Finn.” The larger boy didn’t notice Sam stroking himself but once he did he lost all control.
Sam was experiencing everything but pain. His pleasure couldn’t be described and when Finn began to go faster, he attempted to match Finn’s speed of thrust with the speed of his jittering hand on his ready to explode dick. And then Finn whispered, “Do it, Sam. Come for me.” And he was gone, his whole body tensed and it was like no other orgasm. Come erupted and landed all up his chest, covering his abs completely. His moans were cut off by Finn kissing him, vibrating through Finn’s mouth. As Sam came, Finn felt everything. And when Sam’s body tensed around his dick, he couldn’t stop himself, coming inside of him with a couple thrusts before stopping and practically collapsing on top of Sam, his come smearing all over his chest.
Sam looked up in euphoria at Finn’s sweat glistened face. Their breaths pressed against each others faces. He was speechless, he couldn’t say anything but then his moaning said it all.
“Are you okay? I didn’t hurt you did I?” Finn broke the silence, and then kissed Sam’s neck just once before pulling out him and ridding himself of the come filled condom and grabbed his boxers and began to clean Sam off.
“No, god no!” Sam smiled his breathing beginning to go back to normal. “Finn, that was... -“
“Amazing?” Finn breathed.
“Yes! Just wait, you’ll see what I mean.” Sam kissed Finn a little as he lay next to him, his hands resting against his hot chest.
“No way! Dude, you’re huge. I mean I know I’m not small, but jesus Sam.” Finn wasn’t refusing completely; he was just a bit shocked. He definitely wanted to try it, but Sam’s endowment was certainly something to be weary of.
“Really? I mean, Finn you’re pretty big yourself and you felt perfect.” Sam smiled, clearly understanding that Finn had some body issues but the way he tried to over them with the duvet so Sam couldn’t see him naked. Sam pushed the duvet away and climbed on top of Finn again with a devilish grin. “And you’re fucking hot.”
“Okay, okay!” Finn laughed as Sam straddled him. “I’ll let you do it but tomorrow okay? You totally wiped me out dude.”
“Perfect!” Sam smiled in triumph. “You’ll love it. I swear.”