10 Maybe-Favorite Books [EDIT]

Nov 07, 2006 11:57

This falls into the category of "Innapropriate Things To Think About While You're Sitting Sesshin". And I'm not entirely sure that these are my actual _favorites_, just some I like and think are significant - or have just liked for a very long time ( Read more... )

reading, sesshin

Leave a comment

Comments 6

drl909 November 7 2006, 23:01:24 UTC
Bill Watterson, actually. I want to be contrary and argue that the Calvin and Hobbes compilation shouldn't count because it's not prose, but hell, I put Watchmen on my list, right? Right. And Calvin and Hobbes has more depth than a lot of more so-called "serious" work.

Reply

BILL!!! crainefish November 7 2006, 23:14:17 UTC
Yep. Total brain fart. How embarassing - no wonder it didn't sound quite right...

Not sure what "Watchmen" is about - but Bill Watterson is my hero. Define "serious". :-)

Incidentally, if I can claim all of Harry Potter as one book, the Hitchhiker... err... Trilogy could easily be construed as a single book too, no?

Reply

Re: BILL!!! drl909 November 7 2006, 23:24:31 UTC
Incidentally, if I can claim all of Harry Potter as one book, the Hitchhiker... err... Trilogy could easily be construed as a single book too, no?

Rowling has pretty much conceived and written the Potter books as a unit... a long story with a definite beginning and a definite end. The Hitchhiker's novels are very definitely not executed this way. (Douglas claimed that he didn't even really want to write So Long as a Hitchhiker's novel, or even write Mostly Harmless at all... he just wanted a definitive reason to stop writing Hitchhiker's novels, which is why Mostly Harmless ends the way it does. For that matter, Asimov also claimed to have written the later Foundation novels under duress.)

Reply

Re: BILL!!! drl909 November 7 2006, 23:40:55 UTC
Oh, yeah, while I'm at it...

1. By "serious" I mean "not funny."

2. Watchmen is a comic book miniseries about superheroes. But it's not a superhero story. It's a story that's about something else that just happens to involve (or more accurately, costumed vigilantes... only one character in the entire book has honest superpowers). It's the only piece of superhero literature I've ever read that really, truly, seriously questions the necessity of superheroes.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up