Unpopular opinions

Jan 01, 2010 23:26

 Is it possible that Synecdoche New York is the best American movie of the decade?  Much as I love There Will Be Blood ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 14

inkstuds January 2 2010, 05:59:33 UTC
I loved it. the closest we will ever come to a chris ware movie.

Reply


drogochideseter January 2 2010, 19:32:56 UTC
I am so not into saying that something is the best something. I like Synecdoche New York more than therewillbeBLOOD and both are good and funny. I would recommend watching it again because you can appreciate the ridiculousness/visual more from a distance instead of feeling all freaked out like your watching your own life play out in a super fast and unsatisfying way.

Reply

cwright January 2 2010, 21:39:54 UTC
I wasn't really seriously suggesting that There Will Be Blood was inferior or anything it's just that it's topping all the best of lists, and everybody seems to be forgetting about Synecdoche. Or not forgetting, it just wasn't popular. In 20 years I think people are going to look back at it and go "holy shit"

If the human race still exists in 20 years.

Reply


rumrug January 3 2010, 21:35:40 UTC
"Synecdoche New York" is a terrific movie, and I think many critics feel this but are reserving judgment for repeat viewings. However, Roger Ebert (probably the most mainstream film critic?) already believes it's the best of the decade:

http://blogs.suntimes.com/ebert/2009/12/the_best_films_of_the_decade.html

(The rest of his list is kind of all over the place though.)

Reply

cwright January 4 2010, 03:48:06 UTC
Yeah I saw that earlier today, at least he agrees with me!

Reply

cwright January 4 2010, 03:49:19 UTC
And also I agree about the rest of his list... What the fuck?

He's such a weirdo cause he is so erudite about film but then ends up championing things like "Knowing"

Reply

rumrug January 4 2010, 04:17:10 UTC
Yeah, I don't really look to him for recommendations, but he's a really good writer, and usually that means I can tell if I'm going to agree with him about a movie or not. (Which is often more valuable than just a recommendation.)

But, I wound up watching "Knowing" because of him! Urgghh.

And "Crash"--jeez! I'd forgotten that he likes that movie.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

cwright January 4 2010, 20:58:32 UTC
It's great, I'm just warning you.

Reply


anonymous January 4 2010, 19:32:00 UTC
Yeah, I love that movie.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up