I've now been doing this long enough that I've done
year-in-review concert listings from 2003 through 2013, sans 2005 which got skipped for some reason. Here's my show of the year pick from each of those years:
2003 -
Solomon Burke w/ The Black Keys @ Cain Park2004 -
Laibach @ Beachland Ballroom2005 - Steve Earle & the Dukes w/Allison Moorer @ House of Blues (no write-up; extrapolated from list 8 years later)
2006 -
Cowboy Junkies @ Kent Stage2007 -
The Mekons @ Pats in the Flats2008 -
Firewater @ Beachland Tavern2009 -
Mission of Burma @ Studio-A-Rama2010 -
We Were Promised Jetpacks @ Grog Shop2011 -
Medeski, Martin & Wood w/Dr. Lonnie Smith and Will Bernard @ Playhouse Square (Tri-C JazzFest)2012 -
Josh Ritter & The Royal City Band @ Kent Stage2013 -
Yo-Yo Ma and Kathryn Stott @ Finney Chapel The most amazing thing about this list is that Sharon Jones & the Dap-Kings never finished first in any given year. Hopefully they'll get plenty more chances to take the title!
Edit 12/18/2016: Today, I realized that I wrote up the 2006 summary before I went to see Sharon Jones at the Beachland Ballroom on 12/29/2006. I'm not saying that would have changed the final ranking... but I'm pretty sure it would have.