Essay Challenge

[daveydee_2]

There can never be enough good HP essays to be read and to be written and it’s forever and a day since I wrote one.

Additionally, it seems like everybody except me has works in progress. That is a wrong I am about to right.

Not having anything in particular up my sleeve, I am challenging you to set me an essay. Any HP related subject will do

Comments

[major_dallas]

I know one I'd like to see from your viewpoint Dae... Harry and/or his scar a Horcrux? The idea of course is to explore the text and Jo's comments to come up with a likely answer. It is fastly becoming a Hot Topic accross the fandom, rivaling the Ship Wars, though not as nasty ;)

That or Snape's loyalties... gee I'm choosing the most popular subjects aren't I?

Cheers

[heatherhobbit]

Snape: Friend or Foe?

[tunxeh]

Who's the spy in the Order now?

[mrs_bombadil]

I'll resist the urge to ask for something shippy (although I'd love to hear your thoughts on H/G) but I'll ask these big questions instead:

Harry: will he kill, be killed, neither, both, or some other variation?

[heatherhobbit]

It took every ounce of self-control I had to not ask him about Ginny. :D

[xray2000]

Hey Daveydee. How about Snape's relationship with Lily? Was there one? Did Snape tutor Lily in potions?