Fic: A Minstrel of Gondor, 3

Apr 24, 2014 19:24

The next-to-last piece of this story, in which the minstrel makes a choice.

Read more... )

really?, elves

Leave a comment

Comments 7

lferion April 25 2014, 00:38:40 UTC
Oh, Arthen, not unaware. Not at all unaware, though I do not know quite why Thranduil let you perceive so much.

Reply

dbalthasar April 25 2014, 17:37:14 UTC
Not unaware at all. (And there is another piece coming. :-)

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

dbalthasar April 25 2014, 17:37:39 UTC
Thank you! It's a complicated choice.

Reply


amenirdis April 25 2014, 02:21:09 UTC
I love the bit about language too, the differences between them, the hard-won knowledge of the difference between men and elves.

You have perfectly captured that they are not of the daylight world, that Thranduil is fey. Why has he let him see? His motives are as obscure as those of elves seem to the mortal world. Splendid and strange and different, this is an elven king Shakespeare would recognize. (Marlowe's Midsummer Night's Dream?)

Reply

dbalthasar April 25 2014, 17:39:22 UTC
Thank you! Arthen doesn't see the why, and probably never will, and without it can only make the choice he makes.

Reply


penknife April 25 2014, 09:55:26 UTC
Oh, Arthen! And, oh, Thranduil. Who will go this far toward answering the question of whether there's something real beneath the dream -- and Arthen really doesn't want that question answered.

Reply

dbalthasar April 25 2014, 17:40:23 UTC
Yes, that - if this is the reality, then Arthen doesn't think he wants it. And he has fame and - if not fortune, at least a very nice living - waiting for him in Gondor.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up