Leave a comment

Comments 26

eatdrink_bemary May 13 2010, 02:46:01 UTC
I LOVED IT.

You captured their voices so perfectly. It wasn't at all like some of the ridiculous OOC fics you read. I could ACTUALLY see this happening. And mad props on your research and quest for historical accuracy. That kind of thing tickles me pink.

Ice cream, adventures and complements, in a Holmesian sort of way; he would be saddened tomorrow when he woke up and the world was back to normal.

This line is AWESOME, and quite how I think I'll feel tomorrow when I wake up and realize this story is over. Then I'll smile recalling how great it was.

Thanks for sharing and keep up the fantastic work! :D

Reply

dealliasnape May 13 2010, 21:51:50 UTC
Historical accuracy is a fairly large twitch of mine, and I really wanted to make certain what I imagined could really happen.

I'm glad they were in character, their personalities are so wonderful, I hate to write them any other way.

Thank you so much for your lovely review, I'm so glad you enjoyed it. Thank you!

Reply


damnednforsaken May 13 2010, 06:10:03 UTC
I know I told you I'd go and write that fill, but I really wanted to read this first. I'm so glad I did! This was so wonderfully written and in-character. It's given me a terribly wonderful warm and fuzzy feeling. I should really go write that fill, but I kinda wanna read this again...

Great job, bb!

Reply

dealliasnape May 13 2010, 21:54:24 UTC
LOL, to write or read, that is our dilemma...

Warm and fuzzies FTW! I'm glad you liked it, bb! Thank you for commenting!

Reply


ewanspotter May 13 2010, 06:14:18 UTC
This is lovely! Like the perfect blend of movie and Canon. (I reeeeally thought the letter writers was going to be Moriarity.)

Reply

dealliasnape May 13 2010, 21:55:35 UTC
HA! Moriarty would have been a great twist! (And the thought is now sending me in alternate ending giggles.)

I'm glad you liked it, thank you so much!

Reply


ilcocoabean May 13 2010, 22:54:30 UTC
Oh gosh, I hardly ever comment on fics these days but I had to take the time to do so after reading this. It was precious, beautiful and so so sweet. I loved every bit of it and I was dying at the "Mr. Popkin" bit, it was just so perfectly Holmes. XD

And that last line made me go "AWWWW" so loud that people are still staring at me.

I loved your dialogue too, it felt so much like them. ♥

Reply

dealliasnape May 14 2010, 01:34:45 UTC
Thank you so very much! And I'm glad you took the time to give such a lovely review, I appreciate it. Thank you again!

Reply


guardianangel_x May 14 2010, 23:30:59 UTC
That was beyond wonderful- by far the best Holmes/Watson story I've read yet! And I personally LOVED your historical info at the end- LMAO I love that kind of stuff too. :D

Reply

dealliasnape May 15 2010, 03:43:20 UTC
Oh, thank you so very much! I'm flattered you enjoyed it so! And yes, historical research FTW!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up