debate_arena

(Untitled)

the__lord wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 12:17

Debate #5

Home: lovecrafty

Away: mrexcess

Topic: Israel plans to strike Iran nuke targets - US response.

(Untitled)

the__lord wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 12:16

Debate #4

Home: killtacular

Away: brainlesswonder

Topic: Death Penalty

(Untitled)

the__lord wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 12:13

Debate #3

Home: the_sicilian

Away: the__lord

Topic: Al-Qaeda's ability to launch new attacks.

(Untitled)

the__lord wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 12:03

Debate #2

Home: badlydrawnjeff

Away: cargill

Topic: Immigration

(Untitled)

the__lord wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 11:58

Debate #1

Home: imaybeparanoid

Away: skaloop

Topic: Social Security Reform

Hmm...

colintj wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 11:39

not that it matters, but i'll give the edge to skaloop, though it would've been for either side to give me frickin somethning to go on, since its my go at this bastard.

or maybe not, given chuck's surgery. get drunk and debate myself it is.

(Untitled)

the__lord wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 11:02

The results for this week are in, and the standings have been updated. Congratulations to all of this week's winners.

You can use this thread to discuss the results of the Week 1 debates, and make predictions on the Week 2 debates. The Week 2 debates will be posted within the hour.

The debate between colintj and thechuck_2112 has been postponed until the week ( Read more... )

(Untitled)

skaloop wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 07:39

( Results... )

(Untitled)

meredith_mae wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 06:13

Although colintj recovered towards the end, his initial floundering, and killtacular's consistently good arguments forced me to cast my vote for killtacular.

Immigration

somnambulisa wrote in debate_arena Mar 14, 2005 08:17

Since it would be unethical for me to judge based on my personal opinion of US/Mexican immigration, and it would likewise be unethical for me to judge based on my projections of the given arguments (what I think could have been said), and because the burden of proof was in the court of the__lord, my vote goes to fireuzer. If, however, the__lord had used the pronouns "they" ( Read more... )