Good things can be done by people

Oct 01, 2009 21:33

One for you Mr. Gates I reckon. If one person can do that with old scrap, why can't a single Western Democracy style government do anything remotely competent with 10's of $Bn?

Leave a comment

Comments 8

andygates October 1 2009, 20:48:25 UTC
Outstanding! (Old bicycle parts always end up in this sort of thing: old bicycle parts rock the Appropriate Technology world)

Not sure why you link it to the west though - his designs are inefficient and don't scale (a blade mill like that is about 20% compared to a HAWT closing in on the theoretical max 60%); he doesn't have nimbies and planning to contend with (lucky git!) and the community demands are very slim. Which isn't to detract an ounce from his awesome coolness, just that one self-educated kid and his scrapbuild do not, necessarily, reflect on the huge demands and complications of the western power setup.

Reply

skean October 2 2009, 08:01:38 UTC
I read Mr DSP's comment not so much as applying to the specific, more to the general, something like:

"One motivated inidividual has significantly changed the lives of many people in his environment with limited resources; contrast that with the huge resources available to Western Democracy style governments that have failed to significantly change the lives of the people in their environment".

Reply

andygates October 2 2009, 12:11:49 UTC
But there was room to improve. It's not about the resources, it's about the vacuum into which one can innovate.

Reply

andygates October 2 2009, 12:33:43 UTC
In fact, I'd say that innovation is inevitable once the vacuum has been identified. Kamkwamba had a whole different paradigm to his peers.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up