Winners: Challenge 10: Set

[stillxmyxheart]

The winners of Challenge 10 are behind the cut! Round winners will also be posted soon!



First (Tie!)
(5 pts)
Second
(4 pts)
Third
(3 pts)




+











cold_queen_5 + dumbstruckk
w/ 16 votes
rowofstars
w/ 14 votes
jelly_head91
w/ 10 votes

Best Overall Icon (Tie!)
(2 pts)
Mod's Choice
(1 pt)


+





alura_embrey + rowofstars
w/ 2 votes
ssensations

SET 1




misskitty373 || 09/01 || 1a: ♥ 1c: ♥
+++ - no comment
++ - Very nice use of texture.
++ - no comment
+ - Good coloring, crops and I like the strong coloring and text on the 3rd one.
+ - I like the really vibrant colors used, and the creative use of brushes.

SET 2




cold_queen_5 || 16/01 || 2c: ♥
+++ - really lovely uses of cropping
++ - Like the cropping choices, especially 2 and 3.
++ - The soft texture unifies the icons as a set.
++ - no comment
++ - the lighting is brilliant
++ - no comment
+ - love the b/w icon
+ - no comment
+ - no comment

SET 3




alura_embrey || 09/02 || 3b: ♥♥
+++ - bases are sharpened, coloring's great
+++ - I like the different styles in every icon. I love the coloring on a and the cropping and look on b.
++ - the caps chosen represent their emotions well
+ - no comment

SET 4




dumbstruckk || 16/01 || 4b: ♥ 4c: ♥
+++ - Lovely soft coloring.
+++ - no comment
+++ - The coloring is intense, and the lighting and crops are lovely.
++ - love the lighting
++ - I really like the coloring on these and I love the feel of c.
+ - Lovely!
+ - I like the depth in the colouring and that the emotions are clearly portrayed.
+ - no comment

SET 5




ssensations || 04/01 || 5c: ♥
+++ - The emotions are so clear in these. I could nearly feel them myself.
+ - great cropping, great coloring

SET 6




jelly_head91 || 10/01 || 6a: ♥ 6b: ♥
+++ - It has a natural feel to it & I like the clarity of icons A and B.
+++ - no comment
++ - Excellently done.
++ - no comment

SET 7




rowofstars || 14/02 || 7a: ♥ 7c: ♥♥
+++ - no comment
+++ - no comment
+++ - the brightness really works so well for these
++ - no comment
+ - vivid colouring throughout the set
+ - Your color scheme is very nice in 7a and 7c, though 7b seems rather bland in comparison.
+ - no comment

Congratulations!

You can view the tally board here. Feel free to check it whenever you see fit.