[Round Two] Challenge #02 | Voting

Nov 07, 2008 19:25

This week, we've had one dropping out and three skips, but nevertheless we've had awesome entries, and I'm really curious on who wins...

Message from the mysterious host:

So, you've thought of ways to cross the chasm, have you? Except... not everyone survives. Let's see who survives and who doesn't, I'll be waiting. *inset evil laugh*

★→ Anyone ( Read more... )

!mod, challenge 02, round two

Leave a comment

Comments 8

anonymous November 7 2008, 21:12:44 UTC
trickle November 8 2008, 00:13:54 UTC
Please don't use the words "I" & "me".

Reply

anonymous November 8 2008, 00:15:23 UTC
trickle November 8 2008, 00:17:06 UTC
To be safe, it's best not to use the words entirely. It'll also be more fair even if it was used in a manner that does not seem like a personal opinion. Thanks for understanding :)

Reply


anonymous November 8 2008, 05:57:53 UTC
trickle November 8 2008, 09:04:29 UTC
Could you change your critique for your first icon, it's not meeting the criteria of a critique, it seems more like a rant to me.
And just to clarify matters, the icon works as the lyrics were from a song that was from Digimon so it still fits the theme.
Thanks :) I am sorry if I'm seeming like a naggy mod but it's just that I feel the need to clarify matters at times. Sorry if I'm annoying to you ^^;;;

Reply

anonymous November 8 2008, 09:21:54 UTC
trickle November 8 2008, 11:27:40 UTC
Hmmm.. It doesn't seem much of a critique yet. The first part is still an opinion. Could you redo it again? Look at the icon and critique on the quality of the icon, any flaws that you see instead of concentrating on how different from the other icons it is.

Reply


anonymous November 8 2008, 11:01:35 UTC
trickle November 8 2008, 11:28:47 UTC
Yes. I didn't notify Kerri before she posted it so that's why.
No worries, only one icon will be eliminated. We're just adding the second critique for lesser quality icons to be more ascertain as to who will be eliminated aka no ties.

Reply


trickle November 10 2008, 00:19:46 UTC
VOTING IS CLOSED

Reply


Leave a comment

Up