☎ comment with your username + 3-10 icon samples and people will comment with 2 things they like about your icons, and 2 things that you need to improve. ☎ no wank. ☎ pimp! :)
+ Love your crops and subjects, dude + Texture use is awesome - A lot of them are a bit too yellow and washed out. - Urghu, I suck at coming up with crits...
+ i like the coloring in the 3rd and 7th ones, it's really pretty. + your use of textures is totally amazing. - some of your icons are a bit too dark (the 5th, 6th, and 10th ones mostly.) - i don't have another crit ;;
- Some of your icons are a bit too dark - Maybe it's a matter of personal opinion, but the fourth icon looks kind of... ridiculous. No offense, I just hate the squished head thing.
+ Your crops are amazing! + As is your coloring (especially on the ninth icon)
+Your colorings are pretty awesome. I like how you consider the icon instead of sticking some coloring on it and calling it a day. +You make a lot of different types of icons, which attracts different watchers. Which you know, it's always a good thing to have a lot of people enjoy your icons.
- Some of your crops are so obscure that I really can't get what's going on at all. I'm referring to the third, seventh, and ninth icon. But I can't blame you too much, sometimes I can't help but to go with crazy crops personally. - I'm not sure what else, gosh I'm bad at this crit thing.
Comments 43
( ... )
Reply
+ everything else
- seriously I'm not sucking up to you, but I can't think of anything wrong
Reply
+ Texture use is awesome
- A lot of them are a bit too yellow and washed out.
- Urghu, I suck at coming up with crits...
Reply
+ your simple compositions (pretty coloring and not overloaded with textures)
- sometimes I think the blue exclusion layer is too strong for some icons
Reply
( ... )
Reply
+ your use of textures is totally amazing.
- some of your icons are a bit too dark (the 5th, 6th, and 10th ones mostly.)
- i don't have another crit ;;
Reply
- Maybe it's a matter of personal opinion, but the fourth icon looks kind of... ridiculous. No offense, I just hate the squished head thing.
+ Your crops are amazing!
+ As is your coloring (especially on the ninth icon)
Reply
+ good, bold, creative compositions without a ton of textures
- some are blurry and need sharpending
Reply
( ... )
Reply
( ... )
Reply
+You make a lot of different types of icons, which attracts different watchers. Which you know, it's always a good thing to have a lot of people enjoy your icons.
- Some of your crops are so obscure that I really can't get what's going on at all. I'm referring to the third, seventh, and ninth icon. But I can't blame you too much, sometimes I can't help but to go with crazy crops personally.
- I'm not sure what else, gosh I'm bad at this crit thing.
Reply
- the crops are all very extreme and makes it a bit difficult to tell what the subject is
Reply
( ... )
Reply
+ Your cropping is interesting without being ridiculous
- Sometimes your anime icons seem a little oversharpened (the second one here)
- Other than that, nothing else! I suck at crit too.
Reply
Leave a comment