(no subject)
Challenge #8 Results
Eliminations
patchedrobes
with -4 points
Peers Choice
squishysquidgy
with +1 points
malibu_xo_rain
with +1 points
Mods Choice
vereine
Voting Tally
1. -1+1+1 = +1
2. +1 = +1
3. -1-1-1-1 = -4
4. +1-1-1+1 = 0
5. -1-1-1 = -3
Comments
1 -1+1+1
this could work really well, but its hard to read the text
2 +1
the darkening around the charachter really works well with the expression, and then the text really works well with the whole mood of the icon. love it!
3 -1-1-1-1
It looks like nothing was done to the picture in coloring. The text doesn't look well where it is placed.
The font is a tad too big, and the polaroid frame too thick. The image is also slightly pixelated.
Too fuzzy/blurry.
the image is blurry. The placement of the polaroid makes the image inside look odd as it doesn't seem to focus on anything (Oliver just seems like an orange mass). The text doesn't seem fitting, because nothing in the image shows any food, or anything to symbolise something "yum"
4 +1-1-1+1
The picture is really cute, the coloring is great, and I like the boxes and tiny text at the top. It's just a really good icon. :)
It looks a touch too screened making the white kitten look too washed out.
actualy like this a lot, but i think maybe the contrast could be brought down a bit.
kitties! ♥
5 -1-1-1
I like the idea of this icon but the picture doesn't really fit. You can only see a little of him so you don't really know what your looking at.
The light texture doesn't make much sense here, and the cropping doesn't seem to fit the round circle.
the image is too small. The darkness of the border doesn't mesh well with the image, because of the dark blue in that hat Oliver is wearing. The colours of the hat and border blend together too much, which makes the round image seem even similar.
jsilverywitch will be making the banners this week (Peers choice & Mods Choice), so they will be posted when done :)