Rumble Challenge 05 Voting
Welcome to voting for our fifth rumble challenge!
Voting will consist of selecting your three favorite icons and giving reasoning as to why you think they are the best of the bunch. We hope to make these icon makers feel great and to help them build on their skills without resorting to negativity. Voters will also be asked to take a look at the icons from the previous week and select who has shown the most significant improvement over their previous icon, and give reason as to why the icon is a success. Please do not vote for your own icons.
Voting selection should be made on the merit of the icon, not the character pictured.
Voting will end on July 27, 2009 at 11:30 P.M. EST.
All participants will receive an extra point in the challenge for voting.
See last weeks icons here.
Sample Vote:
1st: #19 - The coloring is really eyecatching, and the crop shows a great eye! The lines are very clean and it is altogether very pleasing to the eye.
2nd: #17 - The texture used suits the emotion of the cap perfectly and the font is a great fit as well. This maker seems to show a real mastery of working with black and white.
3rd: #24 - The use of texture in this icon is really impressive and the placement of the text really pulls the icon together. The composition is gorgeous and I would happily make this my default icon forever and ever.
Most Improved: This week's most improved is Nakoma! The coloring on this icon is really great and the placement of the character is very strong. Way to go!
Voting
1234
5678
91011
Voting will consist of selecting your three favorite icons and giving reasoning as to why you think they are the best of the bunch. We hope to make these icon makers feel great and to help them build on their skills without resorting to negativity. Voters will also be asked to take a look at the icons from the previous week and select who has shown the most significant improvement over their previous icon, and give reason as to why the icon is a success. Please do not vote for your own icons.
Voting selection should be made on the merit of the icon, not the character pictured.
Voting will end on July 27, 2009 at 11:30 P.M. EST.
All participants will receive an extra point in the challenge for voting.
See last weeks icons here.
Sample Vote:
1st: #19 - The coloring is really eyecatching, and the crop shows a great eye! The lines are very clean and it is altogether very pleasing to the eye.
2nd: #17 - The texture used suits the emotion of the cap perfectly and the font is a great fit as well. This maker seems to show a real mastery of working with black and white.
3rd: #24 - The use of texture in this icon is really impressive and the placement of the text really pulls the icon together. The composition is gorgeous and I would happily make this my default icon forever and ever.
Most Improved: This week's most improved is Nakoma! The coloring on this icon is really great and the placement of the character is very strong. Way to go!
Voting
1234
5678
91011