Okay the final round! Voting is very different this time, we want to see a fav and a negative in EACH category (try to do all but if you can't that is also fine just state N/A in the area so the mods know).
Challenge Two Sign-ups The Doctor
+1: The colour is fantastic and the text is well placed
-2: THe image is too grainy and it detracts from the main subject
The Villian
+3: The crop is very interesting and draws the eye
-1: The main subject is out of focus and detracts from the icon
The Love Interest
+2: Fantastic use of text and composition
-3: The crop is too far away making it hard to see what the icon is of
Note these are just guides not actual comments on the icons themselves.
The Doctor
001
002
003
The Villian
001
002
003
The Love Interest
001
002
003