Round 4, Challenge 1, Results
Thank you all for voting, al the entries were gorgeous but unfortunately we have to say goodbye to one iconmaker.
For those still in the competition, the next challenge will be up soon!
Voted Out:
evening_road with -5 votes
Favourite:
canadian_turtle with +4 votes
Mod's Choice:
green_queen
Votes:
1: -3 +1
2: -1 +1
3: +4
4: -1 +1
5: -3
6: -2 +2
7:
8: -3
9: -5
Comments:
negative
1- choice of text size/font/colour overshadows the focus of the image, the image is also very contrasted
1- The black and white is great, but it needs more contrast to pop Dom from the background more.
1- Not enough contrast in the black and white, the text is a weak colour and the font doesn't fit.
2- The split screen seems a little off for the chosen photo.
4- the colouring is quite dull and darkish. it's also difficult to see the word 'dominic' from its background.
5- very contrasted and oversharpened
5- The icon is to overpowering and the B&W doesn't work very well.
5- it's oversharpened
6- The coloring is too dark
6- The colouring is a bit dark
8- the texture is out of place, it seems to have no 'meaning' to be there, nor does it blend with the image.
8- The paper seems to be completely random and have no purpose in the icon...
8- it's original but the composition is unbalanced, texture is too big for the small image
9- Dom seems too yellow
9- The feel of the text doesn't go with the icon.
9- The colours don't have enough definition and the text doesn't work. The font is all wrong.
9- The colouring on Dominic is a bit to green
9- The coloring is a bit too yellow for my taste, and the font doesn't seem to fit.
positive
1- Nice use of B&W
2- lovely simplicity with a "sdfgh hands" extra. :D
3- Great coloring !
3- The most interesting icon, with nice bright colours and good use of space.
3- Awesome colouring, and that texture is awesome too!
3- no reason given
4- no reason given
6- Simple, but great cropping and coloring
6- The coloring is gorgeous, simplistic and neat.
For those still in the competition, the next challenge will be up soon!
Voted Out:
evening_road with -5 votes
Favourite:
canadian_turtle with +4 votes
Mod's Choice:
green_queen
Votes:
1: -3 +1
2: -1 +1
3: +4
4: -1 +1
5: -3
6: -2 +2
7:
8: -3
9: -5
Comments:
negative
1- choice of text size/font/colour overshadows the focus of the image, the image is also very contrasted
1- The black and white is great, but it needs more contrast to pop Dom from the background more.
1- Not enough contrast in the black and white, the text is a weak colour and the font doesn't fit.
2- The split screen seems a little off for the chosen photo.
4- the colouring is quite dull and darkish. it's also difficult to see the word 'dominic' from its background.
5- very contrasted and oversharpened
5- The icon is to overpowering and the B&W doesn't work very well.
5- it's oversharpened
6- The coloring is too dark
6- The colouring is a bit dark
8- the texture is out of place, it seems to have no 'meaning' to be there, nor does it blend with the image.
8- The paper seems to be completely random and have no purpose in the icon...
8- it's original but the composition is unbalanced, texture is too big for the small image
9- Dom seems too yellow
9- The feel of the text doesn't go with the icon.
9- The colours don't have enough definition and the text doesn't work. The font is all wrong.
9- The colouring on Dominic is a bit to green
9- The coloring is a bit too yellow for my taste, and the font doesn't seem to fit.
positive
1- Nice use of B&W
2- lovely simplicity with a "sdfgh hands" extra. :D
3- Great coloring !
3- The most interesting icon, with nice bright colours and good use of space.
3- Awesome colouring, and that texture is awesome too!
3- no reason given
4- no reason given
6- Simple, but great cropping and coloring
6- The coloring is gorgeous, simplistic and neat.