A Brief Diversion

Apr 22, 2010 07:00

Is which's (?whiches) a word, like whose?

Consider:

The mixed group of dogs rushed about, vocalizing in a most distressed manner. Which's bark, or howl or moan, was the most disturbing?

Or, if you think that even generic dogs are human enough to require who, then:

The scientists had set up a display with half a dozen species of cockroaches. You ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 3

arch_scrivener April 22 2010, 14:19:49 UTC
Just use which. Yes, it's imprecise. It's not the only gap in the language, and far from the most annoying. Second-person singular vs. plural pronouns, for example.

Reply


jeffr23 April 22 2010, 16:16:19 UTC
By analog with "its", the apostrophe seems deeply incorrect to me, even considering that "which is" doesn't contract.

Reply


entheos April 22 2010, 18:28:30 UTC
I would use the "which one's" construct in both cases.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up