The drsmax favorite sentence meme

Apr 13, 2005 11:02

Copy all of this with obvious modifications:

The drsmax favorite sentence meme ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 15

raygunn_revival April 13 2005, 15:27:01 UTC
Whose sentence is that? Your own?
Quine?
Fodor?

Reply

drsmax April 13 2005, 16:24:01 UTC
The first is Quine, from the first page of Word and Object.

The second is Leyner from somewhere in the middle of My Cousin, My Gastroenterologist.

Reply


bd1 April 13 2005, 15:33:52 UTC
My favorite sentence is:

I eschew obfuscation. That's why I abhor sesquipedalian tendencies.

Reply

drsmax April 13 2005, 16:15:27 UTC
Your favorite sentence is two.

Reply

bd1 April 13 2005, 17:15:45 UTC
Okay wise guy, so what if I can't count?

I eschew obfuscation; that's why I abhor sesquipedalian tendencies.

Reply

drsmax April 13 2005, 18:25:20 UTC
Vun! Vun sentence! Ah ha ha ha ha!

*thunder strikes. bats screech*

Reply


uberdionysus April 13 2005, 19:44:47 UTC
Entification begins at arm's length; the points of condensation in the primordial conceptual scheme are things glimpsed, not glimpses.

Weird.

Entification being the making of entities?

Things glimpsed as opposed to sense-data? So I form the idea of an entity after seeing it, not from the act of seeing? I guess I'm not following.

Reply

drsmax April 13 2005, 20:13:37 UTC
The idea is that first you acquire the concept of an object, and only later do you aquire the concept of a sense datum.

In your terminology: you see thing, form and idea of those things, and only later do you form the idea of seeing.

Reply

uberdionysus April 14 2005, 02:24:34 UTC
So the concept of 'seeing' would be an 'emergent' property? Like: you see a thing, but only after putting thing in 'Unique Object Part of Larger Class of Similar Objects' do you start to form the concept of entities (or of seeing)?

I guess I don't get the difference between 'things glimpsed' and 'glimpses'. Is Quine saying that the sense datum isn't as important as the way we categorize the sense datum?

Jeesh. I never read Quine but that sentence packs a whole lot of stuff. Someone told me he's funny - is that true?

Reply

drsmax April 14 2005, 12:12:07 UTC
I say "yes" to your first and third questions ( ... )

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

drsmax April 14 2005, 23:37:10 UTC
I'm totally into it. However, I must confess to not knowing what libretto is, and I'm too much of a lazy ass to google it.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

drsmax April 15 2005, 00:08:10 UTC
Ok, cool. I'm totally into it. I'll email you a bunch of stuff.

Reply


The Smelly Silent Kid's been writing!? since he left WPU... anonymous April 16 2005, 15:14:38 UTC
hey, if you could, take a quick look and feel cozy inside that you helped shape my paranoid manifestations by talking to me about fire extinguishers in your coolass classroom.

:"Sampson, Simpson, I stick to my story. I'm from Jamaica, MON."
:"Oh yeah? If you're from Jamaica, what part of Jamaica are you from?"
:"Right next to the beee-ach, BOY-EEEE!"

Reply


Leave a comment

Up