Comments | dwrewatch: CAGE MATCH WOOO

_thirty2flavors in dwrewatch

CAGE MATCH WOOO

Feb 12, 2011 14:00

SO here is the final cage match poll, based on the winners for the cage match polls for each season & the specials.

Poll Most of these were pretty clear-cut, except s3 which was one vote away from being a 3-way tie (runners-up being Human Nature/Family of Blood and Blink). S5 was probably the biggest margin, with Vincent & The Doctor winning by an ( Read more... )

poll

Comments 82

rose_griffes February 12 2011, 19:55:44 UTC

I do not understand this obsession with crazy-eyed Ten and cannot condone it!

:-P

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 20:00:36 UTC

LOL WHAT'S NOT TO LOVE?

( ... )

rose_griffes February 12 2011, 20:12:31 UTC

I've never been a collector of .gifs, so imagine a .gif of Nine looking all happy and saying that everybody lives. :D Also, sparkly things in the air! (Also, me huddling behind my chair, hoping nobody asks "Are you my mummy" or ever wears a gas mask again.)

(Crazy-eyed Ten is just... well, he's a flavor of Ten that I was a bit tired of by the end, yeah?)

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 20:22:52 UTC

I sort of go back and forth on my thoughts on TEC/TDD but that moment at the end IS pretty epic.

Waters of Mars is my favourite because I think it kind of sums up what I liked so much about RTD's Who. I can see how it wouldn't be for everyone but I basically think it is unendingly brilliant, lol.

Thread 10

(The comment has been removed)

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 19:57:50 UTC

Midnight is great too. I think the s4 poll gave me the hardest time picking an absolute favourite, though I went for Turn Left in the end.

(The comment has been removed)

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 20:03:14 UTC

Midnight is probably the spookiest episode IMO. I remember just being delightfully creeped out the whole time.

Thread 7

lacunaz February 12 2011, 20:04:10 UTC

I think if Midnight had made it to the Cage Match I would be flailing with uncertainty right about now, but it didn't so I think now my way forth is clear.

Sorry, Impossible Planet.

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 20:07:41 UTC

YOU HAVE DONE WELL.

( ... )

lacunaz February 12 2011, 20:16:11 UTC

( ... )

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 20:18:41 UTC

I think it won because of Utopia, but I'm really surprised too; the last time I had looked at the poll results, Human Nature and Blink were within 1 vote of each other, and the finale was way behind. I dunno what happened. I think mostly people were voting for Utopia, but it was still an unexpected twist. I like TSOD and moments of LOTL but they don't compare to the awesome of Human Nature in my mind.

I was surprised and a little pleased that Blink didn't win for s3.

LOL I do too. I am sort of proud though since it would be my second choice and I don't really expect WOM to win. SO GET IT, TURN LEFT.

ivydoor February 12 2011, 20:16:34 UTC

TURN LEFT.

( ... )

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 20:24:25 UTC

TURN LEFT IS THE ONLY ACCEPTABLE VICTOR IF IT CAN'T BE WATERS OF MARS.

I am lacking in Donna gifs too. Actually, I'm sort of lacking companion gifs in general, except maybe Amy.

firstofoct February 12 2011, 20:38:15 UTC

excus u TIP/TSP is flawless

( ... )

_thirty2flavors February 12 2011, 20:41:07 UTC

I like TIP/TSP but it doesn't have enough fire or crazy Ten.

Thread 19

jedi_of_urth February 12 2011, 21:31:19 UTC

TIP/TSP vs. TL vs. WoM? That's pretty rough. (And it's not like the other ones are bad but there's a clear dividing line between CANNOT CHOOSE and LIKE BUNCHES.

But I think it has to be TIP/TSP because, well...it's TIP/TSP.

_thirty2flavors February 13 2011, 01:09:09 UTC

Yeah I like all of these but the only ones close to the ~crown in my heart are Turn Left and Waters of Mars. I like TIP/TSP, but not as much as I looove Turn Left and Waters of Mars.