Rnd5-Chal2: Results

[narniacmr]

Unfortunately we have to say good-bye to one icon maker :(
I hope you stick around to vote and for the comeback round!

Comments

[alinemcb54]

Can I have the comments for the icon #3 please ?

[alinemcb54]

Can I have the comments for the icon #3 , so I can know what changes make to the new icon please

[galato]

I would like to read the comments for number 5, please :)

[narniacmr]

I missed a vote so you have -2 & +2 = 0.
Here are your comments:
Negative:
#05 - It's dull and sort of dingy. Perhaps either a touch of color to Emma''s skin or make Emma black and white.
#05 - the texture work is lovely but the coloring makes emma look dull and pixelated in the face.

Positive:
#05 - The way the texture’s patterns seamlessly blend in with Emma’s dress really help the subject and the background sync together. It’s also done without overwhelming the subject by the soft lighting textures used and the dark space up around Emma’s head. It helps bring the eye to her face. A very gorgeous icon.
#05 - Nice crop and floral textures catches the eye.