First of all, I would really have liked to have seen a little more explanation on your choice of Kobayashi Maru answers (at least questions 20-22; what you put on 19 was perfect), but it's OK, I've got plenty to go off of here
( ... )
Re: Tacticalgeeky_snarkerApril 10 2010, 22:08:40 UTC
Yay, thanks! :D (and sorry about not adding more to the Kobayashi Maru section, I couldn't think of anything more to say.)
Re: Chakotay and Paris--I always forget that Chakotay was in fact an officer for a time for some reason. But putting that into the picture, yeah, I can now see why he was willing to make an alliance with Janeway. And it was the smart thing to do, I suppose. On Paris, I read the book Pathways by Jeri Taylor, and its section on Paris explained a lot about why he was who he was. I don't know if you've read it, so I won't spoil it, but it gives a very good reason for Tom being such a jerk at first. And poor Doctor. never could get a girl.
Re: TacticalpaleogymnastApril 10 2010, 22:16:32 UTC
Ahh, yes, no I haven't read Pathways (and I'm really not a fan of Jeri Taylor), and I actually feel like I *do* understand Tom pretty well (sorry if I forgot to say that, but that was not *my* opinion of him, rather how he comes across to Chakotay)--also remember that Chakotay never had the benefit of reading Pathways so from his perspective, Tom's kind of a spoiled brat who betrayed a whole lot of people (Starfleet and the Maquis), and it would have taken a long time to get over or get around that bad first impression.
For the record, I actually rather like both Tom and Chakotay, so no hard feelings against either of them.
Re: Tacticalgeeky_snarkerApril 10 2010, 22:52:29 UTC
Ah, yes. True, very true.
For the record, I actually rather like both Tom and Chakotay, so no hard feelings against either of them. Oh, okay. I'm really sorry for misunderstanding.
Tactical Trackpure_rhubarbApril 10 2010, 22:48:28 UTC
I agree with paleogymnast, I would have liked to see more explanation on your Kobayashi Maru. However, you have given me enough to see that you belong in Tactical!
Like the others, I would have liked to have seen more to your Kobayashi Maru answers, but it doesn't stop me from placing you in a track.
I'm just going to say: YES, DR MCCOY! i'm always pleased to see other people who like mccoy as much as me :D (also, i very much approve of the fact that you dislike chakotay for being mean to tom! tom was my FAVOURITE and i never forgave him, either!)
That said, the majority of your choices (and paleogymnast says this much better than I can, point to Tactical.
Comments 19
Reply
Re: Chakotay and Paris--I always forget that Chakotay was in fact an officer for a time for some reason. But putting that into the picture, yeah, I can now see why he was willing to make an alliance with Janeway. And it was the smart thing to do, I suppose. On Paris, I read the book Pathways by Jeri Taylor, and its section on Paris explained a lot about why he was who he was. I don't know if you've read it, so I won't spoil it, but it gives a very good reason for Tom being such a jerk at first. And poor Doctor. never could get a girl.
Reply
For the record, I actually rather like both Tom and Chakotay, so no hard feelings against either of them.
Reply
For the record, I actually rather like both Tom and Chakotay, so no hard feelings against either of them.
Oh, okay. I'm really sorry for misunderstanding.
Reply
Also, yay for the DS9 love!
Reply
Reply
and once again, props for the DS9 love> i get so much crap from my stepdad for liking DS9, he's a TNG fan all the wayy :) best of luck!
Reply
I'm just going to say: YES, DR MCCOY! i'm always pleased to see other people who like mccoy as much as me :D (also, i very much approve of the fact that you dislike chakotay for being mean to tom! tom was my FAVOURITE and i never forgave him, either!)
That said, the majority of your choices (and paleogymnast says this much better than I can, point to Tactical.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment