Comments | eyerenderingfan: *Heavy Angry Sigh* and WTF?

eyerenderingfan

Heavy Angry Sigh and WTF?

Jul 21, 2009 17:21

Okay, so I'm innocently twittering when a tweet catches my eye.

Apprently, I can never ever pretend (EVER) that the charcaters of fall out boy whom we know and love are OUT OF CHARACTER?! According to the queen of live journal;

"Two fics, both chaptered, and so, so out of character and horribly, "PETE AND PATRICK BROKE UP SO NOW PATRICK WANTS JOE ( Read more... )

wtf

Comments 12

rosiedoes July 21 2009, 21:46:40 UTC

1) Passive aggressiveness is lame.

2) Remember how I spent ages trying to help you improve your fic? Remember how Matte did, too?

3) It's funny how I was perfectly nice until I had something negative to say about your writing. I think we call that sour grapes.

4) Fan fiction is about imagining those people in different situations, sure; but there's no point writing a someone completely out of character? You may as well write original fiction.

As I have told you repeatedly, you have the potential to write really decent fic, but you don't think it through and you don't give the actual characters you write the respect that they deserve.

But hey, seeing as I'm 'not nice' I won't try helping you again.

eyerenderingfan July 21 2009, 22:01:21 UTC

Hun, there is nothing I can say that will convince you that what you did-- placing ur rather harsh reflections about the fic on Twitter-- was a good thing.

I totally respected you as a person and writing and thought that if you thought other wise about my fic you would tell me personally and not ur friend over Twitter where I can clearly see it. I was following you becuz I was a fan of yours, duh.

BUT either way, you will clearly point out that number 1:

It's YOUR twitter where you can rant to YOUR friends
2) you are entitled to your opinion
& 3) It's a free fucking country

And I give you all of those, I just wish you had some consideration before you commented like that. Oh and trust me, after this I won't be seeking your guidance anytime soon.

rosiedoes July 21 2009, 22:15:36 UTC

Firstly, I have a lot of people following me and I didn't know you were one of them. It's not as if you even use the same username on there, is it? If I had known you were reading I would have been more tactful, but my view would not have changed ( ... )

eyerenderingfan July 21 2009, 22:34:43 UTC

I've expressed how insanely great-ful I was for the hours and hours of feed back/guidance. I didn't make Patrick a heavy stoner for the whole Fic, in fact, it's only in the very beginning and one other time in the fic he touches the stuff. But it's highly objected. The fact is Patrick may not look like he smokes but he has made reference to it before. I was simply playing off the reference and saying; 'Hey guys, what if ( ... )

Thread 12