Not gonna lie, your review had me dancing around the room. I worried about so many of the things you mentioned--whether the boys were in character, whether their voices were right, whether the curtain!fic bent would be boring--so I'm over the moon that all those things made an impression on you. Thank you for reading!
So I don't really do much commenting. And honestly, if you would have said this was a deathfic, I wouldn't have read it. But I did read it and was thoroughly engrossed and then got to Chapter 9 and halfway through I realized you were not going to fix Sam. I finished and was not happy.
Now I can't get the damn thing out of my head and to top it off when I got off of work it was snowing these big beautiful flakes of snow and all I could think of was Sam was out there somewhere making it snow. And I kind of hate you a little bit for writing something that is sticking with me so strongly and making my heart break.
So this is why I suck at commenting. This is meant to be a positive review.
...I just read your end comments. I feel slightly better that Sam is not dead. But he is still gone and I am still depressed.
I wondered whether I should warn for deathfic or not, but I figured it wasn't technically deathfic since Sam lives at the end. So I warned for angst instead. I'm sorry it wasn't the ending you were hoping for, but thanks for sticking it out anyway! Your story about the snowflakes brought a huge smile to my face--Sam making it snow was one of my favorite parts to write. Hugs for being depressed? :)
You have killed me, I kept thinking they were going to find a way to fix Sam. And now i'm left crying my eyes out because they should never be apart, and that last line jesus christ.
Comments 21
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
Now I can't get the damn thing out of my head and to top it off when I got off of work it was snowing these big beautiful flakes of snow and all I could think of was Sam was out there somewhere making it snow. And I kind of hate you a little bit for writing something that is sticking with me so strongly and making my heart break.
So this is why I suck at commenting. This is meant to be a positive review.
...I just read your end comments. I feel slightly better that Sam is not dead. But he is still gone and I am still depressed.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
*sobs uncontrollably*
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment