challenge 1; round 3: results

[redhour]

ELIMINATED \\ dionisia2005


with -4 votes

VOTER'S CHOICE \\ imaginary-lives


with +4 votes | BANNER

MOD'S CHOICE \\ darlingbones


nice crop; the texture and text adds a nice touch. | BANNER

TALLY:
If your number is not listed, you received no comments.
01: -
02: - -
03: - - -
04: + + + + | VOTER'S CHOICE
05: - -
06: - - - - | ELIMINATED

If you'd like to see your comments, reply with your number.

For now on I'm posting comments in the post.
01.
- the coloring is too orange

02.
- icon looks too busy
- the icon is too empty

03.
- such grunge texture is doesn't fit
- the texture used made the icon look weird
- the texture/s and colouring don't compliment the image

04.
+ nice texture use & awesome composition
+ the use of negative space is just beautiful and perfect
+ Nice bold colouring.
+ the coloring is great with that texture

05.
- the patter on the background and the mask are good but angelina herself is a little bright
- Due to the contrast being so high the image appears oversharpened

06.
- colors are too green
- it needs more color
- the texture is quite overpowering and flattens the image
- the texture used makes the icon look ugly