Comments | ffiferoo: Harry Potter and the Sappy Ending

ffiferoo

Harry Potter and the Sappy Ending

Jul 25, 2007 18:40

( This is what I thought of the Deathly Hallows, behind a cut incase anyone finishes it after me (yeah, right) )

Comments 6

pet_the_zebu July 26 2007, 15:30:37 UTC

Rachel, I <3 your review.

oceanhawk July 27 2007, 03:33:53 UTC

"Oh, Snape, you're the only 3-dimensional character, and you're so good at it." That makes me giggle.

Um, I think Harry gave Neville the sword or something...it was actually explained, but it's been a few days for me, so I don't really remember how he got it, but she did have a line about that.

Also, dear, I really think you just made up the whole thing about Lily's eyes in your head. I'm pretty sure the constant mention was just JKR's tendancy to use the same phrases over and over again when describing things. She does it ALL the freaking time.

And yeah, that was totally my thought "Dude, if you love your kid so much why the hell would you name him Albus Severus?"

Did you read my review? Because I agree with you a lot. Like...a lot.

ffiferoo July 27 2007, 03:46:28 UTC

I could swear that there was some specific thing about Lily being like, extra super special and how we were going to find out about it. Maybe it was just a lot of speculation and I didn't remember right.

And yeah, I read yours, and I also agree with much of what you said.

electricice79 July 27 2007, 14:35:04 UTC

http://www.hpana.com/forums/topic_view.cfm?tid=57408&p=1 (#5)

I never read past Goblet of Fire, but I also remembered people talking about how she said it's important that Harry has his mother's eyes.

electricice79 July 27 2007, 14:44:36 UTC

I also feel compelled to introduce this (http://www.leakylounge.com/index.php?showtopic=49124&st=10) thread which speculates that Harry LITERALLY had Lily's eyes transplanted into his head.

fluffycupcake July 29 2007, 15:01:09 UTC

dude. exactly how i felt about the tonks/lupin thing, esp. with tonks turning from an actual character into a smiley face as the book progressed. i just thought it was sweet for rowling to try so hard to make a beard. i mean ... it was obvz that the only reason why lupin was freaking out about a kid was that he realized that he could never replace sirius with tonks, esp. because of the ladyparts, from which babies come. which is gross, so he freaked out, blamed it on being a werewolf, & tried to replace sirius with harry this time, & when he realized that harry was a poor man's substitute, decided to kill himself. which is why we don't hear about how he dies. it's cos he kills himself out of gaygrief. ps: lupin is my dream man, making you awesome for loving him. pps: the whole o yah lupin & tonks died seemed like an afterthought rowling added on after she had initially been to the editor & he was like "um?" & she was like "OHHHHHHHH ok ( ... )